Hotels in Long Island

momondo users most often search for hotels in New York when looking to visit Long Island. The average nightly rate for New York is $474. Other popular destinations in Long Island include Brooklyn and Montauk. Brooklyn has an average nightly rate of $309 and Montauk has an average nightly rate of $244.

Beachcomber Resort At Montauk, located in Montauk, is the top-rated hotel in Long Island with a rating of 9.2. The next best rating is a 9.0 which was given to Montauk Manor by momondo users. The third-highest rated hotel is Aqualina Inn Montauk, which was rated a 9.0 by momondo users familiar with the hotel.

As a popular tourist destination in Long Island, it is no surprise that Montauk has the most expensive hotel rooms at $314 per night - 31% more than than the country's average hotel room price.

Our users typically find that Queens has the lowest nightly rates in the country at just $123. Queens offers hotel rooms at an average rate that is 59% lower than the average city in Long Island.

If you’re planning to stay somewhere in Long Island with your family, then consider booking rooms at Kenny's Tipperary Inn, which is a popular choice among our users with families. Per night prices average $224 for a room at Kenny's Tipperary Inn. Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa ($630 per night) and Montauk Manor ($295 per night) are other popular family hotel options in Long Island.

Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa, Royal Atlantic Beach Resort and Montauk Manor are the top three hotels in Long Island for couples according to our user data. It’s $630 per night on average for a room at Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa, $203 per night for a room at Royal Atlantic Beach Resort and $295 per night for a room at Montauk Manor.

There are 10,224 operators available for hotels in Long Island as of April 2026.

Prices for hotels in Long Island are updated daily.