Hotels in Shelter Island

Find the best deals on 71 hotels in Shelter Island, NY

Check-in
Check-out
Compare vs. momondo |
-
1
Check-in
Check-out

Top Hotels in Shelter Island

Find the perfect Shelter Island hotel for business or leisure


Things to do in Shelter Island

Havens House

What is the average price of a hotel near Havens House?

If you’re planning on staying at any of momondo’s recommended hotels in the area of Shelter Island nearest to Havens House, you should expect to pay around $661/night. This price fluctuates based on time of year. In general, a rate under $661/night is a good deal for momondo users staying near Havens House. Hotels near Havens House are typically 55% more expensive than the average hotel in Shelter Island, which is $297.

Hotels near Havens House
  • Azalea House
    Best value

    Azalea House

    1 Thomas Ave, Shelter Island, NY

    $60

    View Deal
  • Sunset Beach
    #1 Most popular

    Sunset Beach

    35 Shore Road, Shelter Island, NY

    10.0

    $530

    View Deal
  • Shelter Island Sun Filled Waterfront Retreat!
    #2 Most popular

    Shelter Island Sun Filled Waterfront Retreat!

    Shelter Island, NY

    $1,276

    View Deal
  • Charming, Renovated Island Cottage - Shelter Island License #: 012-2017
    #3 Most popular

    Charming, Renovated Island Cottage - Shelter Island License #: 012-2017

    Shelter Island, NY

    9.5

    $343

    View Deal
  • Charming A-frame Home On Private Quiet Road
    #4 Most popular

    Charming A-frame Home On Private Quiet Road

    Shelter Island, NY

    9.8

    $383

    View Deal
  • Stunning Contemporary With Heated Gunite Pool Near Wades Beach
    #5 Most popular

    Stunning Contemporary With Heated Gunite Pool Near Wades Beach

    Shelter Island, NY

    10.0

    $957

    View Deal
  • Charming, Historic Cottage

    Charming, Historic Cottage

    Shelter Island, NY

    $751

    View Deal
  • New Listing: Garden Cottage, Wetlands, Landscaped Gardens, Solar Panels

    New Listing: Garden Cottage, Wetlands, Landscaped Gardens, Solar Panels

    Shelter Island, NY

    10.0

    $799

    View Deal
  • Charming Shelter Island Oasis

    Charming Shelter Island Oasis

    Shelter Island, NY

    10.0

    $525

    View Deal
  • Stylish Shelter Getaway! Private Dock. Heated Saline Pool. Clean & Uncluttered

    Stylish Shelter Getaway! Private Dock. Heated Saline Pool. Clean & Uncluttered

    Shelter Island, NY

    10.0

    $1,067

    View Deal
  • Beautiful, Waterfront Home With Dock And Heated Gunite Pool!

    Beautiful, Waterfront Home With Dock And Heated Gunite Pool!

    Shelter Island, NY

    10.0

    $488

    View Deal
  • Farmhouse Nestled By Preserved Meadow. Pool. Near Beaches and Centrally Located!

    Farmhouse Nestled By Preserved Meadow. Pool. Near Beaches and Centrally Located!

    Shelter Island, NY

    10.0

    $745

    View Deal

When to book a hotel in Shelter Island

Check out the information below to find the best deal on a Shelter Island hotel room
Low Season
December
High Season
August

cheapest month to stay

45%

expected price decrease

most expensive time to stay

28%

expected price increase

Price
$199 - $497
Highest day of week
Saturday
Cheapest day of week
Wednesday

av. price over the last two weeks

Average price (weeknight)

$317

av. price over the last two weeks

av. price over the last two weeks

Average price (weekend night)

$481

av. price over the last two weeks


How much does a hotel in Shelter Island cost per night?

Use the information below to find quality Shelter Island hotel rooms for low prices

Shelter Island travel information

How long do people stay in Shelter Island?

When visiting Shelter Island the average booking length is 1 night.

How much does a hotel cost in Shelter Island?

The cost of a hotel room in Shelter Island will vary according to demand, location and star rating. On average, rooms will cost around $287 per night.

When is the best time to book a hotel in Shelter Island?

Shelter Island hotels are at their most economical to book in the month of December. The rates you are charged may be 45% lower than in the high season and is the best time to get a great deal.

Which day is cheapest to stay in Shelter Island?

The cost of a Shelter Island hotel room will vary for each day but generally Tuesday works out the most economical, with Friday proving the least economical.

How much does a hostel in Shelter Island cost?

Hostels in Shelter Island (including hotels rated 2 stars and below) costs $111 per person, per night on average. This is a $176 per night cheaper than the average cost of hotels in Shelter Island.