Hotels in Shelter Island from $230 - Find Cheap Hotels with momondo

momondo compares 3M+ hotel and accommodation options.

Top hotels in Shelter Island

Find the perfect hotel for your stay in Shelter Island

Price

$230

$1,875

Review Score

Hotel class

Hostels and cheap hotels in Shelter Island

These hotels and hostels usually make for a cheap way to stay in Shelter Island

Shelter Island House

11 Stearns Point Road, Shelter Island, NY, United States

9.2

$230

View Deal

214066

The Rams Head Inn

108 South Rams Island Drive, Shelter Island, NY, United States

7.7

$406

View Deal

215364

House on Chase Creek

3 Locust Avenue, Shelter Island, NY, United States

9.2

$246

View Deal

165119

Charming Studio on Shelter Island

Shelter Island, NY, United States

$447

View Deal

1070438579

Cozy Shelter Island Cottage, walk to beaches and Mashomack Preserve

Shelter Island, NY, United States

9.7

$400

View Deal

7087619

Newly Renovated With Pool, Hot Tub, And Fireplace!

Shelter Island, NY, United States

9.7

$566

View Deal

4019719

Get the best value hotel in Shelter Island

These Shelter Island hotels have the best prices for their ratings

Shelter Island House

11 Stearns Point Road, Shelter Island, NY, United States

9.2

$230

View Deal

214066

Cozy Shelter Island Cottage, walk to beaches and Mashomack Preserve

Shelter Island, NY, United States

9.7

$400

View Deal

7087619

House on Chase Creek

3 Locust Avenue, Shelter Island, NY, United States

9.2

$246

View Deal

165119

Sunset Beach Hotel

35 Shore Road, Shelter Island, NY, United States

8.1

$603

View Deal

190275

The Rams Head Inn

108 South Rams Island Drive, Shelter Island, NY, United States

7.7

$406

View Deal

215364

Newly Renovated With Pool, Hot Tub, And Fireplace!

Shelter Island, NY, United States

9.7

$566

View Deal

4019719

Useful insights on Shelter Island hotels

Get a quick overview on price and accommodation trends for your visit in Shelter Island

Lowest Hotel Price	$230
Hotels Near Airport	528
Average Length of Stay	2 days

The cheapest price for a room in Shelter Island found in the last 7 days is $230/night. This rate is available with Shelter Island House, a 3-star hotel.

There are 528 hotels in Shelter Island close to Islip Long Island. Clarion Hotel & Conference Center Ronkonkoma Macarthur Airport is the nearest with a distance of 0.7 mi from this airport.

On average, people stay for 2 days when lodging at hotels in Shelter Island. The average accommodation price for 2 days in Shelter Island in the past week is $1,622.

When to book a hotel in Shelter Island

Check out the information below to find the best deal on a hotel room in Shelter Island

Prices

When to Book

What is the average price per room type in Shelter Island?

The most popular room type for hotels in Shelter Island is Golf, with an average price of $140/night. The second most popular room type is Family at $388/night, followed by Romantic at $318/night.

What are the hotel prices per star rating in Shelter Island?

The most affordable choice in Shelter Island is a 2 star hotel, with average rates of $530 per night. A 3 star hotel in Shelter Island typically costs $634 per night, while the priciest option is a 4 star hotel, averaging $1,382 per night.

Information about staying in Shelter Island

Read these important travel tips before booking a hotel in Shelter Island

How long do people stay in Shelter Island?

When visiting Shelter Island the average booking length is 2 nights.

How much does a hotel cost in Shelter Island?

The cost of a hotel room in Shelter Island will vary according to demand, location and star rating. On average, rooms will cost around $1,144 per night.

When is the best time to book a hotel in Shelter Island?

Shelter Island hotels are at their most economical to book in the month of January. The rates you are charged may be 78% lower than in the high season and is the best time to get a great deal.

Which day is cheapest to stay in Shelter Island?

The cost of a Shelter Island hotel room will vary for each day but generally Monday works out the most economical, with Friday proving the least economical.

Does Shelter Island have vacation rentals?

The city of Shelter Island has vacation rentals available as well as hotels if you’re looking for different accommodation options. At the moment, there are 70 vacation rentals in the city. We recommend booking Waterfront House With Dock And Private Beach for your stay, which is the most popular rental in Shelter Island. Search for deals on vacation rentals in Shelter Island.

How many operators does momondo search for hotels in Shelter Island?

The number of operators available for hotels in Shelter Island is 79 as of September 2026.

When did momondo last update prices for hotels in Shelter Island?

Prices for hotels in Shelter Island are updated daily.

Why use momondo?

Why should I book accomodation in Shelter Island through momondo?

Searching across hundreds of travel sites, momondo finds hotels and accommodation options in Shelter Island and lets you filter them according to your needs. It is free to use and there are no hidden booking fees or costs.

How does momondo help me find a great place to stay in Shelter Island?

You can find a great place to stay in Shelter Island by using our filters once you have used the search form above. The filters momondo offer include simple options such as star rating, location and price; but also go much further and allow you to select accommodation based on style, amenities such as free breakfast and internet as well as enhanced health and safety options.