Shelter Island House

4-star Hotel with Outdoor pool

4 stars
11 Stearns Point Road, Shelter Island, NY 11965
+1 631 749 1633
9.0
Wonderful
based on 45 reviews
45 verified ratings
Thu 6/25
-
Fri 6/26
2 guests, 1 room
Deals from
$214
/Cheapest rate per night
Room type
Provider
Nightly total
Queen room
$214
Deluxe room
$275
King room
$605
10 more Shelter Island House deals
10 more Shelter Island House deals
Bedroom
Bedroom
Bedroom
Other
Bedroom
Bedroom
Other
Bedroom
Other
Bar
Bathroom
Other
Other
Bedroom
Other
Building
Bathroom
Other
Shelter Island House photos
About
Rooms
Amenities
Reviews
Location

About Shelter Island House, Shelter Island

Cleanliness
8.8
Comfort
9.2
Location
9.6
Services
8.3
Staff
9.1
Value for money
8.5
Set in Shelter Island Heights, Shelter Island House is a short walk from Shelter Island Country Club and provides an outdoor pool. Guests can also enjoy complimentary wireless internet. Guests of the hotel can make the most of the property's gardens. Guests also have access to a sun deck. Shelter Island House features 9 rooms, all of which are equipped with a range of amenities to ensure an enjoyable stay. Groton-New London Airport is a 80-minute drive from the hotel. It is also less than a 20-minute car trip from Henry W. Prince Building.

Shelter Island House room price & deals

Thu 6/25
-
Fri 6/26
King room
King room
No inclusions
bed type unknown
$605
nightly with fees
King room
No inclusions
bed type unknown
$624
nightly with fees
King room
No inclusions
bed type unknown
$817
nightly with fees
Queen room
Queen room
No inclusions
bed type unknown
$214
nightly with fees
Queen room
No inclusions
1 queen bed
$230
nightly with fees
Queen room
No inclusions
1 queen bed
$230
nightly with fees
Deluxe room
Deluxe room
No inclusions
bed type unknown
$275
nightly with fees
*Total includes estimated local taxes & fees payable on check out.
Prices are based on 1 night, including fees but not including taxes.

Hotel Amenities & Facilities

  • Outdoor pool
  • Restaurant
  • Bar/Lounge
  • Room service
  • Free Wi-Fi
  • Free parking
  • Flat-screen TV
  • TV
  • Cable or satellite TV
  • Free toiletries

Bathroom

  • Shower
  • Bathtub
  • Bidet
  • Spa bath
  • Hairdryer
  • Toilet
  • Bathrobe
  • Private bathroom

General

  • Family rooms
  • Seating area
  • Garden view
  • Hardwood or parquet floors
  • Interconnected room(s) available
  • Sofa
  • Pool view
  • Storage available

Basics

  • Free Wi-Fi
  • Internet
  • Linens
  • Towels
  • Fan
  • Free toiletries
  • Heating
  • Air-conditioned

Dining

  • Snack bar
  • Restaurant
  • Bar/Lounge
  • Food can be delivered to guest accommodation
  • Dining table

Media and entertainment

  • Flat-screen TV
  • Shared lounge/TV area
  • Cable or satellite TV
  • TV

Things to do

  • Beach access
  • Bicycle rental
  • Board games/puzzles
  • Cycling

Kitchen

  • Refrigerator
  • Dining area
  • Kitchen

Accessibility and suitability

  • Pets allowed on request. Charges may apply.
  • No smoking
  • Private entrance

Outdoor

  • Terrace/Patio
  • Picnic area
  • Garden

Bedroom

  • Sofa bed
  • Clothes rack
  • Wardrobe or closet

Health and safety

  • Daily housekeeping
  • First-aid kit
  • Safe

Services and conveniences

  • Wake-up service
  • Safety deposit box
  • Room service

Pool and spa

  • Massage
  • Outdoor pool

Parking and transportation

  • Free parking
  • Private parking

Family friendly

  • Cribs available
  • Pool cover

Laundry

  • Iron and ironing board

Shelter Island House Reviews

9.0
Wonderful45 verified ratings
Pros +
  • Staff was super accommodating. (in 14 reviews)
  • Thank you Shelter Island House (in 2 reviews)
  • The pastries offered at breakfast were outstanding! (in 3 reviews)
Cons -
  • Be aware that the pet fee is $150 ($167 after taxes). (in 1 review)
  • Restaurant on site was closed. (in 3 reviews)

Shelter Island House room booking info

Value for money

8.5

Location rating

9.6

Distance to city center

1.3 mi

Nearest Airport

Tweed-New Haven

Distance to airport

30.4 mi

Check in/Check out

Check in anytime after 3:00 PM, check out anytime before 11:00 AM

Cancellation/prepayment

Cancellation/prepayment policies vary by room type and provider.

Frequently asked questions

  • How does Shelter Island House compare to other 4 star hotels in Shelter Island?

    Shelter Island House is $577 cheaper than the average 4 star hotel in Shelter Island. You can usually find a nightly rate of $214 when staying at Shelter Island House.

  • How far is Shelter Island House from Tweed-New Haven?

    If you're looking to go directly from Tweed-New Haven to Shelter Island House, expect a 1 hr 31 mins drive as they are around 30.4 mi apart.

  • What is the best way to get to Shelter Island House from Tweed-New Haven?

    If you’re looking for a simple travel option from Tweed-New Haven to Shelter Island House, consider calling a taxi or rideshare service to take you to the hotel as well as around the city during your visit.

  • Is Shelter Island House pet-friendly?

    Shelter Island House welcomes pets at their venue.

  • Are there food options at Shelter Island House?

    Yes, Shelter Island House does have a restaurant where you can sit down to eat or take food to go. There are also many other quality food options in Shelter Island for those looking for something different. Guests staying at Shelter Island House are welcomed by hotel staff to order room service directly from the kitchen to their room.

  • Does Shelter Island House have a pool?

    Yes, Shelter Island House has a pool that customers can use. Typically, hotel pools have restrictions based on the time of day so be sure to speak to the front desk before using the pool.

  • What is the phone number for Shelter Island House?

    If you have questions or concerns about your stay at Shelter Island House, call +1 631 749 1633 to speak with a front desk representative.

  • Does Shelter Island House have Wi-Fi available?

    Yes, Shelter Island House has Wi-Fi available to hotel guests.

  • What time is check-out for Shelter Island House?

    You can plan to arrive after 3:00 PM for checking in. Check-out time is 11:00 AM. We advise notifying the front desk of any requests as early as possible.

  • How much is a room at Shelter Island House?

    The cheapest deals found start from only $213 per night. The average rate for rooms at Shelter Island House is currently around $706/night. Enter your dates in the form above to see more.

  • How many operators does momondo search for hotels in Shelter Island?

    The number of operators available for hotels in Shelter Island is 78 as of June 2026.

  • When did momondo last update prices for hotels in Shelter Island?

    Prices for hotels in Shelter Island are updated daily.

Places of interest near Shelter Island House

Attractions in Shelter Island, New York curated by momondo

Shelter Island House location: 11 Stearns Point Road, Shelter Island, NY 11965

Top landmarks

Manhanset Chapel1.3 mi
James Havens Homestead1.6 mi
Havens House1.7 mi

momondo’s favorite Shelter Island hotels

House on Chase Creek

3 Locust Avenue, Shelter Island, NY

9.2
2 stars

$315

Sunset Beach

35 Shore Road, Shelter Island, NY

7.9
3 stars

$574

Save money when you book hotels with momondo

Best deals on hotels

Best deals on hotels

See deals from 3M+ hotels and accommodations in one place.

Free cancellation

Free cancellation

Use our filter to find stays with free cancellation.

Millions of reviews

Millions of reviews

Check ratings based on millions of real guest reviews.

Price Alerts

Price Alerts

Not ready to book? to track prices.
Search hotel deals

An easier way to manage your Shelter Island trip

We make it super easy to schedule, organize and travel with friends or family. Trips is free — and available to use no matter where you book.
Start using Trips
Find my bookings

Get notified when prices go down

Daily price changes in your inbox - only with Price Alerts.
2 guests, 1 room
Shelter Island House
Thu 6/25
Fri 6/26
By creating a price alert you accept our terms of use and privacy policy.

Find better results for your stay in Shelter Island