Top Hotels
FAQs
Hotels in Shelter Island

Vacation rentals in Shelter Island, NY

Find deals on vacation rentals in Shelter Island, NY

momondo compares 3M+ hotel and accommodation options.

Top rentals in Shelter Island

Find the perfect vacation rental for your stay in Shelter Island
Price
$400
$1,781
Review Score
0+
6+
7+
8+
9+

Hostels and cheap hotels in Shelter Island

These hotels and hostels usually make for a cheap way to stay in Shelter Island
Cozy Shelter Island Cottage, walk to beaches and Mashomack Preserve Photo

Cozy Shelter Island Cottage, walk to beaches and Mashomack Preserve

Shelter Island, NY, United States

9.7
7087619
Newly Renovated With Pool, Hot Tub, And Fireplace! Photo

Newly Renovated With Pool, Hot Tub, And Fireplace!

Shelter Island, NY, United States

9.7
4019719
Charming Studio on Shelter Island Photo

Charming Studio on Shelter Island

Shelter Island, NY, United States

1070438579
Shelter Island Retreat With Pool, Home Theater, Close To Beach & Pet Friendly Photo

Shelter Island Retreat With Pool, Home Theater, Close To Beach & Pet Friendly

Shelter Island, NY, United States

9.8
1070549876
Waterfront House With Dock And Private Beach Photo

Waterfront House With Dock And Private Beach

Shelter Island, NY, United States

10.0
4145718
Waterfront Estate on Shelter Island - 200 Feet of Waterfront - 100 Foot Dock Photo

Waterfront Estate on Shelter Island - 200 Feet of Waterfront - 100 Foot Dock

Shelter Island, NY, United States

9.8
3229054

Get the best value vacation rental in Shelter Island

These Shelter Island vacation rentals have the best prices for their ratings
Cozy Shelter Island Cottage, walk to beaches and Mashomack Preserve Photo

Cozy Shelter Island Cottage, walk to beaches and Mashomack Preserve

Shelter Island, NY, United States

9.7
7087619
Shelter Island Retreat With Pool, Home Theater, Close To Beach & Pet Friendly Photo

Shelter Island Retreat With Pool, Home Theater, Close To Beach & Pet Friendly

Shelter Island, NY, United States

9.8
1070549876
Waterfront House With Dock And Private Beach Photo

Waterfront House With Dock And Private Beach

Shelter Island, NY, United States

10.0
4145718
Waterfront Estate on Shelter Island - 200 Feet of Waterfront - 100 Foot Dock Photo

Waterfront Estate on Shelter Island - 200 Feet of Waterfront - 100 Foot Dock

Shelter Island, NY, United States

9.8
3229054
Newly Renovated With Pool, Hot Tub, And Fireplace! Photo

Newly Renovated With Pool, Hot Tub, And Fireplace!

Shelter Island, NY, United States

9.7
4019719
Waterfront With Private Beach Boat Dock And Launch Ramp Photo

Waterfront With Private Beach Boat Dock And Launch Ramp

Shelter Island, NY, United States

10.0
6921716

Useful insights on Shelter Island vacation rentals

Get a quick overview on price and accommodation trends for your visit in Shelter Island

Average Length of Stay

2 days
On average, people stay for 2 days when lodging at vacation rentals in Shelter Island. The average accommodation price for 2 days in Shelter Island in the past week is $1,439.

Information about staying in Shelter Island

Read these important travel tips before booking a vacation rental in Shelter Island

How long do people typically book vacation apartments for in Shelter Island?

About 2 nights is the most common choice for those booking vacation apartment rentals in Shelter Island.

When is the best time to book a vacation rental in Shelter Island?

Vacation apartments in Shelter Island are often cheapest in September - rental prices can be around 29% lower than the average during this period.

How many operators does momondo search for hotels in Shelter Island?

The number of operators available for hotels in Shelter Island is 77 as of September 2026.

When did momondo last update prices for hotels in Shelter Island?

Prices for hotels in Shelter Island are updated daily.

Save money when you book vacation rentals with momondo

Best deals on hotels

Best deals on hotels

See deals from 3M+ hotels and accommodations in one place.

Free cancellation

Free cancellation

Use our filter to find stays with free cancellation.

Millions of reviews

Millions of reviews

Check ratings based on millions of real guest reviews.

Price Alerts

Price Alerts

Not ready to book? to track prices.

An easier way to manage your Shelter Island trip

We make it super easy to schedule, organize and travel with friends or family. Trips is free — and available to use no matter where you book.
Start using Trips
Find my bookings

Get notified when prices go down

Daily price changes in your inbox - only with Price Alerts.
2 guests, 1 room
Mon 9/28
Tue 9/29
By creating a price alert you accept our terms of use and privacy policy.

Find better results for your stay in Shelter Island