Hotels in Montauk from $137 - Find Cheap Hotels with momondo

There are 479 hotels in Montauk close to Islip Long Island. Clarion Hotel & Conference Center Ronkonkoma Macarthur Airport is the nearest with a distance of 0.7 mi from this airport.

On average, people stay for 2 days when lodging at hotels in Montauk. The average accommodation price for 2 days in Montauk in the past week is $500.

When to book a hotel in Montauk

Check out the information below to find the best deal on a hotel room in Montauk

Prices

When to Book

What is the average price per room type in Montauk?

The most popular room type for hotels in Montauk is Spa/Wellness, with an average price of $696/night. The second most popular room type is Family at $861/night, followed by Budget at $402/night.

What are the hotel prices per star rating in Montauk?

The most affordable choice in Montauk is a 2 star hotel, with average rates of $259 per night. A 3 star hotel in Montauk typically costs $266 per night, while the priciest option is a 4 star hotel, averaging $437 per night.

Information about staying in Montauk

Read these important travel tips before booking a hotel in Montauk

How long do people stay in Montauk?

A stay of 2 nights is most popular when visiting Montauk.

How much does a hotel cost in Montauk?

Hotels in Montauk show a range of prices for their rooms. These are determined by factors such as availability, locale and amenities. On average, rooms will be around $395 per night.

When is the best time to book a hotel in Montauk?

Room prices for hotels in Montauk can be as much as 45% lower in the month of February. So this is a great time to book and save money.

Which day is cheapest to stay in Montauk?

At the moment the cheapest day to stay in a hotel in Montauk is Sunday, with Friday being the most expensive.

Based on the weather in Montauk, what attractions are popular during May?

With generally low rainfall expected (2.2″) and an average temperature of 57.2 °F, those staying at a hotel in Montauk may want to take some time during their visit to go see popular landmarks in the area. Considering the weather during May, attractions worth visiting near Montauk are Madison Square Garden, Rockefeller Center, and Broadway.

Does Montauk have vacation rentals?

Yes, there are 608 vacation rentals in Montauk. At the moment, North Harbor Montauk is the most popular Montauk vacation rental based on our user data. Search for vacation rentals in Montauk.

How many operators does momondo search for hotels in Montauk?

As of May 2026, there are 343 operators available to choose from for hotels in Montauk.

When did momondo last update prices for hotels in Montauk?

Prices for hotels in Montauk refresh daily.

Where to stay in Montauk

What neighborhood in Montauk should I stay in based on why I’m traveling?

If you are visiting Montauk in the summer months and want to enjoy a beach vacation, then you should consider staying in Montauk Beach. Montauk hotels by the beach include Beachcomber Resort and Breakers at the Ocean. A stay at Montauk Beach still gives you proximity to the restaurants in Montauk’s city center while offering seaside proximity and a beautiful view of the ocean. If you are traveling with kids or are looking for a more low-key atmosphere away from the popular bars, then a hotel at the bayside of the island where the water is calmer could suit you nicely. Settle in at Montauk Manor or Ruschmeyers Hotel for a relaxed ambiance. If you want to stay by the beach but are traveling on a budget, then you should take a look at Napeague Beach on the southern side of Montauk. Here you can find cheap hotels in Montauk’s vicinity, like Windward Shore Ocean Resort and Ocean Colony Beach & Tennis Club.

Why use momondo?

Why should I book accomodation in Montauk through momondo?

Booking accommodation or a hotels in Montauk is made easy with momondo. We are free to use and there are no hidden costs or fees. momondo compares hundreds of websites and gives you all your Montauk hotels and accommodation options in one place.

How does momondo help me find a great place to stay in Montauk?

momondo offers numerous filters to help you find a great place to stay in Montauk. You can filter by star rating, freebies such as free breakfast or internet as well as review scores, location and price.