Car Rentals in Montauk, New York

Are you looking for cheap car rental deals in Montauk, New York? Search right here!

Montauk, NY
Aug 15 — Aug 22
Same drop-off
Montauk, NY
Mon 8/15
Noon
Mon 8/22
Noon

Best deals found for Montauk, New York car rentals

Find great deals below on a variety of popular rental cars in Montauk, New York
Chrysler 200
or similar Standard
Up to 5 passengers
4-door vehicles

$148/day

22 Aug - 24 Aug
Chrysler 200
Hyundai Avante
or similar Standard
Up to 5 passengers

$148/day

22 Aug - 24 Aug
Hyundai Avante
Toyota Camry
or similar Full-size
Up to 5 passengers

$152/day

22 Aug - 24 Aug
Toyota Camry
Subaru Outback
or similar Full-size
Up to 5 passengers

$152/day

22 Aug - 24 Aug
Subaru Outback

Montauk, New York car rental deals found on momondo

Find the rental car in Montauk that's right for you

Small Cars

$73 - $250

All Car Types

$69 - $217

The average price of a Small rental in Montauk, the United States is $99. The cheapest time to rent a Small in Montauk, the United States is in December. The price is 27% lower than the rest of the year at just $73 per day. A Small rental is typically 4% less expensive than the average car rental in Montauk. The average price of a vehicle rental in Montauk can vary based on a number of factors including supply, popularity of the vehicle, and how far out you book your rental car.

The average price of a Medium rental in Montauk, the United States is $91. The cheapest time to rent a Medium in Montauk, the United States is in December. The price is 39% lower than the rest of the year at just $57 per day. A Medium rental is typically 11% less expensive than the average car rental in Montauk. The average price of a vehicle rental in Montauk can vary based on a number of factors including supply, popularity of the vehicle, and how far out you book your rental car. Below are the best prices for Montauk Medium rentals found on momondo in the past week.

The average price of a Large rental in Montauk, the United States is $84. The cheapest time to rent a Large in Montauk, the United States is in September. The price is 0% lower than the rest of the year at just $101 per day. A Large rental is typically 18% less expensive than the average car rental in Montauk. The average price of a vehicle rental in Montauk can vary based on a number of factors including supply, popularity of the vehicle, and how far out you book your rental car. Below are the best prices for Montauk Large rentals found on momondo in the past week.

The average price of a SUV rental in Montauk, the United States is $67. The cheapest time to rent a SUV in Montauk, the United States is in September. The price is 14% lower than the rest of the year at just $58 per day. A SUV rental is typically 35% less expensive than the average car rental in Montauk. The average price of a vehicle rental in Montauk can vary based on a number of factors including supply, popularity of the vehicle, and how far out you book your rental car.


Montauk car rental directory

All major car rental suppliers in Montauk, New York
3.9
Mediocre
11 reviews3 locations
Overview

Cleanliness

5.9

Comfort

3.4

Overall

3.9

Pick-up/drop-off

4.9

Value

2.4
3 locations
2 locations
1 location
0.0
Horrible
2 reviews1 location

Quick facts about car rentals in Montauk

Get the overview on great rental deals, popular car rental companies, and best car types for your visit in Montauk

Popular Car Types

SUV, Compact, Intermediate

Cheapest Rental Car

$87

Most Popular Model

Ford Fiesta
The following car types were offered at rental car companies in Montauk in the past 72 hours: SUV, Compact, Intermediate.
The lowest price for a rental car in Montauk is $87/day. For this area, you can expect average prices starting from $116/day.
The most popular car model to rent in Montauk in the past 7 days is the Ford Fiesta.

Find popular attractions close to your rental car pick-up

Visit these must-see attractions near popular rental car locations in Montauk

Nearby attractions:

Hither Hills State Park58.7 mi
Montauk Downs State Park63.1 mi
Ditch Plains Beach64.0 mi
Lake Montauk64.3 mi
Montauk Point State Park67.0 mi

Nearby attractions:

Montauk Point State Park50.5 mi
Lake Montauk52.3 mi
Montauk Downs State Park53.4 mi
Ditch Plains Beach53.6 mi
Hither Hills State Park57.8 mi

Nearby attractions:

Hither Hills State Park48.8 mi
Montauk Downs State Park51.3 mi
Lake Montauk52.1 mi
Ditch Plains Beach52.7 mi
Montauk Point State Park54.6 mi

Rent a car near one of these popular hotels in Montauk

Below are the most popular hotels in Montauk

Driving with a rental car in Montauk - FAQs

Learn everything there is to know about renting a car in Montauk so you can be properly prepared for your next trip

Most people will rent an Economy car when traveling to Montauk during the month of September. Its efficient gas mileage and ability to handle wet road conditions makes the economy car a go-to choice when precipitation averages 3.7″ and temperatures hover around 57.2 °F. Renting a Economy in Montauk will cost you $180/day on average.

Travelers who rent a car in Montauk should be aware that the city’s speed limit is 25 mph. Suburban speed limits around Montauk are generally 75 mph, whereas speed limits on highways are 75 mph. Keep in mind that speeds may change depending on what road you’re traveling on, so be on the lookout for posted signage.

Typically, the weather in Montauk through the month of August is 71.6 °F and the expected precipitation is 3.9″. This is important information to know when renting a car so you can be sure to rent the perfect car for the expected weather.

The climate in New York during August is usually 69.8 °F with an expected 3.7″ of precipitation throughout the month. Those looking to rent a car and leave from Montauk on a road trip to the surrounding area should take note of this information.


Car rentals at popular airports near Montauk

Rent a car at any of these most popular airports near Montauk

Explore more car rentals in the United States

Check out rental car deals within the United States

Start planning your trip to Montauk


Why use momondo?

Choosing momondo to search for rental cars in Montauk makes sense because it is quick and free of charge. We find all the rental car prices and policies, you simply choose what works best for you and your trip.

momondo helps you find the best car rental deal in Montauk by allowing you to filter results by price, capacity, car features, drop off, pick-up location and many more.

Free cancellation is a policy that can be filtered on momondo car rental searches for Montauk and all other locations. Availability may vary by location.

Yes, momondo has a filter for fair fuel policies on car rentals in Montauk.

You certainly can. momondo has a dedicated filter for enhanced cleaning services for all car rental locations including Montauk.

momondo offers a filter specifically for unlimited mileage on car rentals in Montauk.


Here's why travelers choose to use momondo
Book with confidence
We compare rental car deals from over 70,000 locations, allowing you to make a quick and easy choice.
Eco Conscious
Choose from a range of vehicles including hybrid and electric options to ensure your travel is environmentally friendly.
No Hidden Costs
All prices shown will be in full. No hidden costs or charges so you have confidence in the price you see.