Hotels in Sanibel Island

Adorable Coastal-Themed 1 Bedroom Condo on Captiva - Snook Villa at South Seas 3118, located in Captiva, is the top-rated hotel in Sanibel Island with a rating of 10.0. The next best rating is a 10.0 which was given to Ground Floor Condo Steps From The Beach Sanibel Island 3B1 by momondo users. The third-highest rated hotel is Sanibel Island Condo With All Of The Amenities 2C2, which was rated a 10.0 by momondo users familiar with the hotel.

While there are many hotels in Sanibel Island to choose from, Sanibel Island Beach Resort (8.3 rating from 1,845 reviews) happens to be the most popular among our momondo users. In the past 12 months, 36% of all our users who looked at hotels in Sanibel Island opted to stay at Sanibel Island Beach Resort.

$270 per night is the average price for a double room at a hotel in Sanibel Island during the month of December. The cheapest rate for a double room in Sanibel Island during this month was for $183 per night (in Sanibel).

At just $213 per night, Sanibel has hotel room rates that are 52% less than other cities in Sanibel Island.

While there are plenty of family hotels to choose from in Sanibel Island, the most popular among our users is Sanibel Island Beach Resort, which costs around $316 per night on average. South Seas and Sundial Beach Resort & Spa are also great family hotels in Sanibel Island. South Seas has rooms for $485 per night on average, while Sundial Beach Resort & Spa has rooms for $539 per night.

For a couples getaway in Sanibel Island, our users often book a room at either Sanibel Island Beach Resort ($316 per night), Sundial Beach Resort & Spa ($539 per night) or Tween Waters Island Resort & Spa ($294 per night).

As of December 2025, there are 1,941 operators available to choose from for hotels in Sanibel Island.

Prices for hotels in Sanibel Island were last updated today.