Cheap flights from New York to Costa Rica from $146

The cheapest month to fly to Costa Rica from New York is in May. Flight prices, which tend to average around $392, are often lower during this time because this is during the off-season. If you’re not able to fly to Costa Rica in May, then October is your next best option. Flight prices from New York to Costa Rica during October average around $395.

According to our data, Monday is the cheapest day to fly to Costa Rica from New York. The lowest ticket price found for a Monday departure recently was $407. Keep in mind that prices can always vary depending on your route and whether or not you are flying domestic or international. If your travel schedule is flexible, try to avoid departing on a Thursday because tickets tend to average around $493. These prices are subject to change though, so be sure to set up a Price Alert for flights to Costa Rica.

In the afternoon is the cheapest time of day to fly from New York to Costa Rica when you can find flight prices for as low as $399. Flying to Costa Rica in the afternoon is an ideal time because this is during off-peak travel hours. Flights to Costa Rica are more costly in the evening, with an average ticket price of $469. Departure times in the evening fall within the peak daily travel times, which is why tickets can be more expensive.

Fly from Newark to San José Juan Santamaria Intl for the best New York - Costa Rica flight prices

You are more likely to see cheaper flights to Costa Rica from New York when booking weeks ahead of your departure date. In general, you can expect to find flights to Costa Rica for around $428 when searching weeks out. However, flight prices might be lower outside of this timeframe. For example, people recently found flights to Costa Rica from New York for as low as $393 on momondo.

There are 4 cabin classes available to choose from on New York to Costa Rica flights. Cabin price and availability will vary by airline so perform a search above to find the right deals for you.

JetBlue, Delta, and United Airlines are the most popular carriers operating from New York to Costa Rica

United Airlines, JetBlue and American Airlines are the top three most popular airlines that fly to Costa Rica from New York according to our data. United Airlines is the first choice among our users, with 52% of people opting to fly with this airline when traveling to Costa Rica. Keep in mind that there are 8 different airlines that fly to Costa Rica on a routine basis, so you have a few additional options to choose from.

Historically, on average around 22% of flights between New York and Costa Rica have experienced a delay on any given week. The average delay length over the past 12 months has been 147 minutes.

Generally, flights departing in the morning tend to experience fewer delays. Flights in the evening have, in the past, seen delays more frequently in comparison.

Saturday is statistically the day of the week which experiences the fewest number of delays on this flight route. Sunday has historically seen more delays on average compared to the rest of the week.

According to our data, JetBlue have had the least number of delays on this route over the last 12 months; with about 22% of their flights experiencing any sort of delay.

The number of flights available between New York and Costa Rica is 5 per day as of June 2026. The most frequent departure time is 7:00AM, with 94% of daily flights leaving at noon.

36 flights are operational weekly from New York to Costa Rica as of June 2026. The most popular departure day for this route is Mon, with 17% of flights per week taking off on this day.