Convertible Car Rentals in New York

Are you looking for cheap convertible car rental deals in New York, New York State? Search right here!

New York, NY

May 4 — May 11

Deals from rental companies in 70,000+ locations.

Save money when you book cars with momondo

Best deals on cars

See deals from rental agencies in 70,000+ locations.

Price transparency

See the total cost up front so there are no surprises.

Book with flexibility

Find cars with free cancellation and enhanced cleaning.

Price Alerts

Not ready to book? Create a price alert to track prices.

Search car deals

Rental cars insight and trends in New York

Useful insights to help you book the perfect rental car in New York

Which convertible car rental agency in New York has the cheapest convertible car rental prices?

Renting a convertible car in New York is cheapest when using Hertz at their location in the city. The best daily rate a momondo user has found is $70, but typically it’s best to assume your convertible car rental will cost $122/day.

Which convertible car rental company in New York has the most locations?

Hertz is very popular in New York, New York, as they have more locations than any other convertible car rental company. You can find 19 locations in the city of New York, New York and can expect to pay about $122/day for your rental convertible car in New York, New York.

New York convertible car rental directory

All major convertible car rental suppliers in New York, New York State

Alamo

8.4

Very good

209 reviews•4 locations

Check prices

Overview

Recent reviews

10.0

Wonderful|Aug 2023

The staff are very helpful from pick-up to drop-off

10.0

Wonderful|Jun 2023

Great customer service. Everyone I interacted with was kind, competent, and professional.

10.0

Wonderful|Mar 2023

We received the truck we wanted. Everything was great.

10.0

Wonderful|Feb 2023

Everything was great.

2.0

Poor|Jan 2023

It was not Alamo but Budget as the booking got changed by tripadvisor. a. The car ( nissan murano) at JFK airport was not clean b. After some time the front collision warning light came up kept coming up intermittently c. It applied automatic breaks in the middle of the highway quite a few times ( Lucky to be remain unhurt) d. Had to stop my trip half way and take shelter at a friend's place late in the evening e. Towing truck came way too late f. Replacement vehicle was also dirty g. Replacement vehicle had serious mechanical issue ( shaking vigorously on the highway) h. In spite of all these, was charged for the extra day ! The overall experience with this Budget rental was worse than pathetic!!

10.0

Wonderful|Jan 2023

Very helpful and super fast pick up and drop off. Zero hassles and super helpful staff

1 out of 70

Enterprise Rent-A-Car

8.3

Very good

207 reviews•16 locations

Check prices

Overview

Recent reviews

10.0

Wonderful|Sep 2023

The representative I met in the morning was so nice and friendly. She wanted to get me out of there quick so she gave me an upgrade. Everyone at this enterprise has a great work ethic and sense of urgency helping out their customers. Will definitely go back.

10.0

Wonderful|Aug 2023

Customer service was excellent, Bryan was professional and help me with a good car.

2.0

Poor|Jun 2023

Our experience was terrible. We booked online, and when we arrived we were told that their was no car available. No excuse, no alternative proposed nothing and left us at 10pm with no option than to take an hotel room at our costs and find by ourselves a different option. Disaster.

10.0

Wonderful|Jun 2023

2.0

Poor|Dec 2022

The car was dirty, and had cigarette burns on the inside. The car was also delivered with a half tank of gas. Additionally, we were charged 100 dollars more than quoted.

10.0

Wonderful|Dec 2022

Not sure why I was not able to book using the portal and had to call Kayak.

1 out of 69

View Enterprise Rent-A-Car Locations in New York

Avis

7.0

Good

279 reviews•13 locations

Check prices

Overview

Recent reviews

10.0

Wonderful|Dec 2023

Very efficient and fast. Great staff.

2.0

Poor|Sep 2023

Better maintained car

10.0

Wonderful|Aug 2023

Friendly and quick service. No delays.

8.0

Very good|Aug 2023

Simply and good service.

10.0

Wonderful|Aug 2023

Everything was awesome

10.0

Wonderful|Jun 2023

The car seemed a bit old or poorly maintained, it made a lot of noise and shook violently every time I hit the brakes. But otherwise everything was seamless, I had 0 trouble receiving and returning the car. Avis folks are fast and efficient.

1 out of 93

View Avis Locations in New York

Hertz

6.6

Okay

592 reviews•19 locations

Check prices

Overview

Recent reviews

2.0

Poor|Sep 2023

They didn’t have the car for me which I had thought I reserved.

4.0

Mediocre|Sep 2023

The representative at the counter was helpful but the manager put us in a $53 car when I had paid $69. All he had left was a cheaper electric car and didn't adjust the rate. I thought I was agreeing to a "manager's special" but it was actually a "manager's choice". He made a CHOICE to put me in a lower priced car at a higher price. It was only a two day rental so I only overpaid by $32. The other issue was that I was making a one way, 900 mile road trip and stopping every 200 miles and spending an hour recharging an electric car was unacceptable.

4.0

Mediocre|Sep 2023

Apple Card fiasco. Why take as form of payment if card can’t be validated at pickup?!

2.0

Poor|Aug 2023

I made a reservation but they had no cars to rent.

6.0

Okay|Jul 2023

Showed up an hour late due to airplane. Didn't have my car. Wanted me to wait 2 hours for car, or upgrade at $75.

8.0

Very good|Jul 2023

Would like wave or GPS on monitor. Good mileages but to low to ground!

1 out of 198

View Hertz Locations in New York

Budget

6.4

Okay

793 reviews•8 locations

Check prices

Overview

Recent reviews

2.0

Poor|Jan 2024

Awful experience entirely. Company closed the pickup location and had to pickup at another location far away in traffic, so was delayed by an hour and late for work. The return was even worse, since I called to confirm that the location closer to my home would be open, I got there and they were closed again during normal business hours. Now I had to drive down to the other Budget location, again in traffic and lost another hour of time, because they were so slow to return the car when I got there with 11 people in line waiting with 1 person at the counter. Then, they tried to charge me for an extra day, because I was a few minutes late, even though they had delayed me on the pickup time and the return. Totally unacceptable and lacking any knowledge at all of what customer service is. This is totally unprofessional and as a shareholder, it is completely alarming.

4.0

Mediocre|Sep 2023

Very very busy office so had to wait an hour after a long flight to even be served. The lady in charge was quite rude and didn’t help the situation. Overall bad customer experience in picking the car up.

10.0

Wonderful|Sep 2023

very friendly and efficient customer service, and the car was really good quality and in good condition. couldn’t fault them if i wanted to

8.0

Very good|Sep 2023

The car smelled like a chimney they couldn’t get the smell of cigarettes out

4.0

Mediocre|Sep 2023

The rental rate was just too much.

10.0

Wonderful|Aug 2023

Everything was perfect

1 out of 265

Sixt

6.4

Okay

205 reviews•3 locations

Check prices

Overview

Recent reviews

6.0

Okay|Sep 2023

I arrived about an hour earlier than my scheduled pick up time and the car I had reserved was not on-site. I was offered an upgraded vehicle for same price but had to pay for an extra day (for 1hr)-then proceeded to wait for 30 min for the staff to give me the keys to the vehicle that was easily seen in the parking lot. They did not tell me what the daily rate would be, nor did it show up on the small screen and I signed the rental agreement thinking it was an amended rental agreement to include my other reservation. I was very surprised to see later in the email the entire rental agreement that was for only one day and the cost was almost the same as for my initial multi day reservation. I had a similar issue at another Sixt rental location in Phoenix AZ in which there were additional fees that were added but I didn’t see them on the small screen. I think it would be helpful if they had full screens where we could see all the sections we are signing off on and then the list of charges with the total.

2.0

Poor|Sep 2023

This rental facility has to be one of the worst in the country for being at a major airport. Pick up and drop off we’re terrible. Cars everywhere. Too hard to differentiate between Sixt and the other companies. Signs wrong. Horrible. Felt bad for the staff because the facility is terrible for them to do their job.

2.0

Poor|Jul 2023

They charged me one more day . I dropped the car at 7 PM , and they charged me until the next day. Terrible

10.0

Wonderful|Jul 2023

Hreat

10.0

Wonderful|Jul 2023

Great

10.0

Wonderful|Jul 2023

Diana at JFK airport was fabulous. She was courteous, patient and professional, and went above and beyond to find our family an appropriate car during a chaotic time when flights were cancelled. All the staff at the airport showed a genuine concern for customers and seemed to be very helpful

1 out of 69

Thrifty

6.0

Okay

396 reviews•3 locations

Check prices

Overview

Recent reviews

2.0

Poor|Sep 2023

We reserved a car more than a month before our trip. When we arrived to pickup the car we went through the traditional paperwork. After a while we noticed many people waiting for their car. So I went to the counter to enquirer about my car only to find out that they did not have any cars available. We waited two hours for a car to be available. We got in the car and drove to the gate only to find out that the car couldn't be released due to mechanical issues. Again we waited for another car. The car we got had bald tires on it which I found out after inspecting the car the next morning.

2.0

Poor|Aug 2023

They do not have a car for me in JFK airport. I needed to left the airport and take a subway and bus for my destiny.

2.0

Poor|Jul 2023

You let me rent a car that wasn’t there. I left my hotel and paid for insurance on the rental and got nothing.

2.0

Poor|Jul 2023

Pick up was a mess. Waited nearly 3hrs for my car that wasn’t even on the premiseso

2.0

Poor|Jul 2023

Awful.

2.0

Poor|Jul 2023

Thrifty rejected my reservation due to no international driver's license, even though I could prove my Portuguese residence and provide a valid driver's license!!!

1 out of 132

Dollar

5.9

Fair

625 reviews•6 locations

Check prices

Overview

Recent reviews

2.0

Poor|Aug 2023

I waited 40 minutes for the van pickup at the airport to the dollar rental facility. Show up at the facility and only 1 person behind the counter and over 40 people in line. Waited over 3 hours to pick up the rental car. After customers started Getting upset the manager came out said he is looking for cars. Everyone lost their patience, the manager then said he can’t help behind the desk. Everyone was yelling and upset that he was not helping resolve the situation. Finally got a car over 4 hours later. The worst experience I have ever had

2.0

Poor|Aug 2023

I can safely say I will never attempt to rent from Dollar again. In the midst of our calamity with a cancelled flight and lost luggage at JFK International Airport after traveling 3000 miles, Dollar failed miserably by allowing us to schedule a car rental on line. After feeling the relief of that rental transaction we come to find out upon arriving at the Dollar rental desk that not only your folks didn’t have any one-way rentals but didn’t have any rentals for us at all. Talk about the left hand not talking to the right hand. Additionally, your customer service rep was condescending with no sympathy for our plight. The rental was placed through Hotwire.

2.0

Poor|Aug 2023

Dollar could not deliver the car i paid for in advance. Moreover they did not offer a solution other than wait a call from them. i had to pick up a car which i did not intend to.

2.0

Poor|Aug 2023

Terrible experience. The car wasn’t ready when it was supposed to be. Their cleaners went home or something. Had to wait 2 hours for the car. Then they overcharged me on tax for the rental. Then they started the rental before I even took possession of the car. Then when I tried to return it there wasn’t anyone there and they added 2 hours into my rental even though they are the ones who didn’t have anyone out there to receive it.

8.0

Very good|Jul 2023

Staff was friendly, cost was high.

2.0

Poor|Jul 2023

They didn’t have a car!

1 out of 209

Quick facts about convertible car rentals in New York

Get the overview on great convertible car rental deals and popular convertible car rental companies for your visit in New York

Most Popular Agency	National
Cheapest Convertible car	$90
Most Popular Convertible car Model	Ford Mustang Convertible

The most popular New York car rental agency found on momondo this month is National. Other top choices for car rental companies are Hertz and Alamo

The lowest price for CONVERTIBLE in New York is $90/day. For this area, you can expect average prices starting from $143/day.

The most popular Convertible car to rent in New York in the past 7 days is the Ford Mustang Convertible. Our users also prefer the Class Convertible as an alternative.

Driving with a rental convertible car in New York - FAQs

Learn everything there is to know about renting a convertible car in New York so you can be properly prepared for your next trip

How much will it cost to rent convertible car in New York, New York in April?

Our data shows that for convertible car rental deals during April in New York, you can expect to pay around $141 per day. A particularly good convertible car rental deal might be around $70, which is the lowest quote for New York we've seen so far.

When did momondo last update prices for cars in New York?

Prices for cars in New York are updated daily.

How many operators does momondo search for cars in New York?

There are 131 operators available for cars in New York as of April 2024.

How old do you have to be to hire a car in New York?

Among different countries, including New York, the minimum age for drivers varies. In numerous EU countries, drivers must be 18 years old. To hire a car overseas, you'll generally need to be at least 21, and if you're under 25, a young driver surcharge may be imposed. It's recommended that you review the policy of the rental company you're considering before booking.

What documentation or ID do you need to rent a car in New York?

To rent a car in New York, all drivers must have a valid full driving license. If the license is written in a language other than the language of the country of rental, an International Driving Permit may be required to avoid the risk of potential fines. If you're renting a car abroad, you may also need to provide proof of return travel and accommodation information during your stay. We recommend that you verify with the specific rental company you're booking with.