Find and compare great deals on Payless rental cars in New York
Same drop-off
Payless car rental deals in New York, New York
Find your perfect rental car on momondo
Choose your travel dates to find the best prices
Small
Medium
Large
SUV
Van
Luxury
Small Cars
$53 - $90
All Car Types
$77 - $134
The best time to rent a Small car from Payless in New York, New York is in February when prices are $53 per day on average. $53 per day is 24% lower than the $70 average yearly price for a Payless Small rental in New York. While February may be the cheapest month to rent a Small car from Payless in New York, August is the most expensive. However, you may still be able to find great deals in August on Small rental vehicles from Payless depending on what day you book.
The best time to rent a Medium car from Payless in New York, New York is in April when prices are $40 per day on average. $40 per day is 48% lower than the $76 average yearly price for a Payless Medium rental in New York. While April may be the cheapest month to rent a Medium car from Payless in New York, June is the most expensive. However, you may still be able to find great deals in June on Medium rental vehicles from Payless depending on what day you book.
The best time to rent a Large car from Payless in New York, New York is in September when prices are $48 per day on average. $48 per day is 59% lower than the $117 average yearly price for a Payless Large rental in New York. While September may be the cheapest month to rent a Large car from Payless in New York, November is the most expensive. However, you may still be able to find great deals in November on Large rental vehicles from Payless depending on what day you book.
The best time to rent a SUV car from Payless in New York, New York is in April when prices are $40 per day on average. $40 per day is 56% lower than the $90 average yearly price for a Payless SUV rental in New York. While April may be the cheapest month to rent a SUV car from Payless in New York, June is the most expensive. However, you may still be able to find great deals in June on SUV rental vehicles from Payless depending on what day you book.
The best time to rent a Van car from Payless in New York, New York is in November when prices are $58 per day on average. $58 per day is 51% lower than the $119 average yearly price for a Payless Van rental in New York. While November may be the cheapest month to rent a Van car from Payless in New York, August is the most expensive. However, you may still be able to find great deals in August on Van rental vehicles from Payless depending on what day you book.
The best time to rent a Luxury car from Payless in New York, New York is in November when prices are $77 per day on average. $77 per day is 39% lower than the $126 average yearly price for a Payless Luxury rental in New York. While November may be the cheapest month to rent a Luxury car from Payless in New York, June is the most expensive. However, you may still be able to find great deals in June on Luxury rental vehicles from Payless depending on what day you book.
Everyone was great, friendly staff, ease of pick up and return and good value
4.0
Mediocre|Mar 2023
Could not contact anyone on phone to find my lost Driving license inside the car. Please assist your customers.
2.0
Poor|Feb 2023
They wouldn't rent a car to me because I had a foreign driver's license.
10.0
Wonderful|Nov 2022
Renting from Payless was a great experience. From booking to pick up and drop off, everything was seamless. I got a great car that came with Sat Nav built in which was great as I was visiting from the UK and had no roaming data so could not use Google Maps.
6.0
Okay|Oct 2022
the car had a leaky tire, we were not sold the toll pass when we should have been and the rep was not helpful when we called to get it corrected.
1 out of 12
View Payless Locations in New York
Information about Payless car rentals in New York
Does Payless have a location at New York John F Kennedy Intl Airport?
At the moment, Payless has 1 location at New York John F Kennedy Intl Airport: 305 Federal Circle.
What is the most popular car to rent from Payless while in New York in August?
In August, our users who rent cars from Payless in New York prefer Intermediate rentals. If you’re looking to reserve one of their Intermediate rentals during this month, prices tend to be $93/day on average and $43/day at their lowest. Keep in mind that prices may fluctuate based on how far out you book your rental car, as well as what car model you choose.
What is the cheapest type of car to rent from Payless in New York?
For an average of $93 per day, a Intermediate rental from Payless in New York is your cheapest car rental option. 62% of our users who rented a car in New York from Payless chose to reserve a Intermediate in the past 12 months in order to save money. $93 per day for a Intermediate also happens to be 58% cheaper than the average cost of the most expensive car Payless has to offer, so you can guarantee you’ll save some money by opting for the cheaper car rental.
How many Payless car rental locations are there in New York?
Payless has 2 rental car locations in New York. Their 25 Bowery Bay Blvd location is the most popular according to our user data. In the past 12 months, 59% of our users who looked to rent a car from Payless in New York chose to rent theirs from the Payless location at 25 Bowery Bay Blvd.
When did momondo last update prices for cars in New York?
Prices for cars in New York are updated daily.
How many operators does momondo search for cars in New York?
There are 155 operators available for cars in New York as of July 2026.
How old do you have to be to hire a car in New York?
Among different countries, including New York, the minimum age for drivers varies. In numerous EU countries, drivers must be 18 years old. To hire a car overseas, you'll generally need to be at least 21, and if you're under 25, a young driver surcharge may be imposed. It's recommended that you review the policy of the rental company you're considering before booking.
What documentation or ID do you need to rent a car in New York?
To rent a car in New York, all drivers must have a valid full driving license. If the license is written in a language other than the language of the country of rental, an International Driving Permit may be required to avoid the risk of potential fines. If you're renting a car abroad, you may also need to provide proof of return travel and accommodation information during your stay. We recommend that you verify with the specific rental company you're booking with.
An easier way to manage your New York trip
We make it super easy to schedule, organize and travel with friends or family. Trips is free — and available to use no matter where you book.
This site uses cookies and other tracking technologies for essential, functional, analytical, and advertising purposes. By using the site, you agree to our Terms & Conditions and our Privacy Policy.
For more information about how we process your information, please see our Privacy Policy.
We value your privacy
momondo and its partners wish to use cookies or similar technologies to store and/or access information on and about your device and process personal data such as your IP address, device identifiers etc., in order to improve your experience on the site, to analyze navigation, to offer and measure personalized advertising, and to facilitate sharing on social networks. We also allow the use of third-party cookies (including those from our advertising partners) on our sites.
By clicking 'Accept', you consent to your data being processed by 0 vendors on this web site for the purposes described in this notice. You can review the vendors and their individual processing purposes on the .
To review individual processing purposes and cookie categories, please click ’Select individual purposes’. You can review your choices and withdraw your consent at any time by clicking the ’Privacy Preferences’ link in the page side navigation.