Car rentals in Coney Island, Brooklyn

You can expect to spend around $6 per day on average on a rental car in Coney Island. Depending on what neighborhood you plan to visit, daily rental prices may be as low as $5 per day or as high as $12 per day which is a 59% difference.

The cheapest rental car companies in Coney Island are NextCar for as low as $5 per day, Europcar for as low as $5 per day and Advantage for as low as $5 per day. Keep in mind that these prices were found in the past 72 hours and are subject to change based on when you book your rental, what neighborhood you plan to visit, and what type of car you rent.

Brighton Beach has the cheapest car rentals in Brooklyn. Our users found that Drivo Rent A Car offers the cheapest rental car deals in the city at $32/day on average. Williamsburg is the next cheapest neighborhood for car rentals. Here you can find average daily rental prices from Routes Car & Truck Rentals for $45/day.

Prices for cars in Coney Island refresh daily.

The number of operators available for cars in Coney Island is 10 as of June 2025.

Among different countries, including Coney Island, the minimum age for drivers varies. In numerous EU countries, drivers must be 18 years old. To hire a car overseas, you'll generally need to be at least 21, and if you're under 25, a young driver surcharge may be imposed. It's recommended that you review the policy of the rental company you're considering before booking.

All drivers must have a valid full driving license when renting a car in Coney Island. If the license is written in a different language from the country of rental, an International Driving Permit may be required to avoid the risk of potential fines. If you're renting a car overseas, you may also need to provide proof of return travel and accommodation information during your stay. It is always advisable to check with the individual rental company you're booking with.