Vacation rentals in New Buffalo, MI
Find deals on 306 vacation rentals in New Buffalo, MI
momondo compares 3M+ hotel and accommodation options.
Top rentals in New Buffalo
Find the perfect vacation rental for your stay in New Buffalo
Vacation rentals in popular neighborhoods in New Buffalo
Below are the most popular neighborhoods in New Buffalo to stay in, as well as some of the best vacation rentals in each area
Downtown
Search rentals in DowntownOne of three new suites, walk to beach (#2A)!
New Buffalo, MI, United States
Hydrangea House
New Buffalo, MI, United States
Adorable Downtown Cottage with Firepit, Fireplace, & Yard - Walk Everywhere
New Buffalo, MI, United States
Hostels and cheap hotels in New Buffalo
These hotels and hostels usually make for a cheap way to stay in New Buffalo
Lake Michigan Charmer
Union Pier, MI, United States
Last Minute Beach Getaway, New Buffalo, MI\n
New Buffalo, MI, United States
This is it You Won't Be Disappointed
New Buffalo, MI, United States
Close to Beach, W&D, Pet friendly, Dunes, Casino
Michigan City, IN, United States
Five minute walk to the beach! 3 bedroom, 1 bath cottage.
Union Pier, MI, United States
Simple Cottage Set in the Woods by Lake Michigan
New Buffalo, MI, United States
Get the best value vacation rental in New Buffalo
These New Buffalo vacation rentals have the best prices for their ratings
Lake Michigan Charmer
Union Pier, MI, United States
Close to Beach, W&D, Pet friendly, Dunes, Casino
Michigan City, IN, United States
The Tulip Tree House
New Buffalo, MI, United States
Lighthouse Cottage - Family Friendly Kids and Pets
New Buffalo, MI, United States
Livywood Cottage
New Buffalo, MI, United States
Beachglass Cottage - Family Friendly Kids and Pets
New Buffalo, MI, United States
momondo's favorite vacation rentals in New Buffalo
Learn more about these user-preferred vacation rentals in New Buffalo
Useful insights on New Buffalo vacation rentals
Get a quick overview on price and accommodation trends for your visit in New Buffalo
Lowest Vacation Rental Price | $185 |
|---|---|
Average Length of Stay | 2 days |
When to book a vacation rental in New Buffalo
Check out the information below to find the best deal on a vacation rental in New Buffalo
| Low Season | November | cheapest month to stay |
| High Season | May | most expensive time to stay |
| 40% | expected price decrease | |
| 35% | expected price increase |
Price | $252 - $642 |
|---|
| Cheapest day of week | Wednesday | is the cheapest day of the week to book |
| Highest day of week | Saturday | is the most expensive day of the week to book |
| $341 | ||
| $1,065 |
Information about staying in New Buffalo
Read these important travel tips before booking a vacation rental in New Buffalo
How long do people typically book vacation apartments for in New Buffalo?
About 2 nights is the most common choice for those booking vacation apartment rentals in New Buffalo.
When is the best time to book a vacation rental in New Buffalo?
November is typically when New Buffalo vacation apartment and rental property prices are at their lowest, with prices around 40% lower than the New Buffalo peak season.
What’s the best area of New Buffalo to book a vacation rental in?
The most popular area to book New Buffalo vacation rentals in is Downtown.
How many operators does momondo search for hotels in New Buffalo?
As of June 2025, there are 319 operators available to choose from for hotels in New Buffalo.
When did momondo last update prices for hotels in New Buffalo?
Prices for hotels in New Buffalo are updated daily.