Top Hotels
Insights
FAQs
Hotels in New Buffalo

Vacation rentals in New Buffalo, MI

Find deals on 303 vacation rentals in New Buffalo, MI

New Buffalo, MI
may. 7 — may. 82

momondo compares 3M+ hotel and accommodation options.

Top rentals in New Buffalo

Find the perfect vacation rental for your stay in New Buffalo
Price
$113
$1,332
Review Score
0+
6+
7+
8+
9+

Hostels and cheap hotels in New Buffalo

These hotels and hostels usually make for a cheap way to stay in New Buffalo
Anchors Away Photo

Anchors Away

New Buffalo, MI, United States

8.1
Lake Michigan Charmer Photo

Lake Michigan Charmer

Union Pier, MI, United States

8.5
Whispering Pines Photo

Whispering Pines

New Buffalo, MI, United States

8.6
Square Toe's Last Resort Photo

Square Toe's Last Resort

New Buffalo, MI, United States

10.0
The Tulip Tree House Photo

The Tulip Tree House

New Buffalo, MI, United States

9.2
1 bed/1 bath, 1.5 blocks to beach/town, dog friendly Photo

1 bed/1 bath, 1.5 blocks to beach/town, dog friendly

Union Pier, MI, United States

10.0

Get the best value vacation rental in New Buffalo

These New Buffalo vacation rentals have the best prices for their ratings
Whispering Pines Photo

Whispering Pines

New Buffalo, MI, United States

8.6
The Tulip Tree House Photo

The Tulip Tree House

New Buffalo, MI, United States

9.2
Anchors Away Photo

Anchors Away

New Buffalo, MI, United States

8.1
Lake Michigan Charmer Photo

Lake Michigan Charmer

Union Pier, MI, United States

8.5
Square Toe's Last Resort Photo

Square Toe's Last Resort

New Buffalo, MI, United States

10.0
Blocks to Town, Game Room, Firepit, Huge Backyard Photo

Blocks to Town, Game Room, Firepit, Huge Backyard

New Buffalo, MI, United States

10.0

momondo's favorite vacation rentals in New Buffalo

Learn more about these user-preferred vacation rentals in New Buffalo

Happy Thoughts Cottage

New Buffalo, MI, United States

9.5
$216
Adorable Downtown Cottage with Firepit, Fireplace, & Yard - Walk Everywhere Photo

Adorable Downtown Cottage with Firepit, Fireplace, & Yard - Walk Everywhere

New Buffalo, MI, United States

9.7
$330
Downtown Hideaway Photo

Downtown Hideaway

New Buffalo, MI, United States

9.7
$403
The Moose House Photo

The Moose House

New Buffalo, MI, United States

10.0
$942
Designer Cottage +Guesthouse on large private estate in Grand Beach with Hot Tub Photo

Designer Cottage +Guesthouse on large private estate in Grand Beach with Hot Tub

New Buffalo, MI, United States

10.0
$533
(3 Nt Min!) New Buffalo Home w/ Lake Views & Hot Tub! Photo

(3 Nt Min!) New Buffalo Home w/ Lake Views & Hot Tub!

New Buffalo, MI, United States

9.4
$462
Cozy Union Pier House with Hot Tub, Deck and Backyard! Photo

Cozy Union Pier House with Hot Tub, Deck and Backyard!

Union Pier, MI, United States

9.6
$453
The Barton Street Bungalow. In the heart of New Buffalo, MI. Walk everywhere. Photo

The Barton Street Bungalow. In the heart of New Buffalo, MI. Walk everywhere.

New Buffalo, MI, United States

9.9
$755

Large 3BR w/ pool and parking - near everything

New Buffalo, MI, United States

9.8
$393
Affordable Classic Cottage Charm. Sleeps 8. Internet provided. Photo

Affordable Classic Cottage Charm. Sleeps 8. Internet provided.

New Buffalo, MI, United States

9.6
$354
Adorable Cottage New Buffalo, Mi. Near Grand Beach.1 Bedroom, Sleeps 5 Photo

Adorable Cottage New Buffalo, Mi. Near Grand Beach.1 Bedroom, Sleeps 5

New Buffalo, MI, United States

9.8
$280
Square Toe's Last Resort Photo

Square Toe's Last Resort

New Buffalo, MI, United States

10.0
$178
Beachglass Cottage - Family Friendly Kids and Pets Photo

Beachglass Cottage - Family Friendly Kids and Pets

New Buffalo, MI, United States

9.3
$263
Eagle's Beach Nest Photo

Eagle's Beach Nest

New Buffalo, MI, United States

9.8
$291
Private Beach, Sleeps 8, dog friendly. Steps to the Beach.\n Photo

Private Beach, Sleeps 8, dog friendly. Steps to the Beach.\n

Union Pier, MI, United States

9.7
$1,087
Livywood Cottage Photo

Livywood Cottage

New Buffalo, MI, United States

9.3
$264
Charming New Buffalo Cottage Photo

Charming New Buffalo Cottage

New Buffalo, MI, United States

9.9
$301

Merchant Street Retreat

New Buffalo, MI, United States

3.0
$299

Romantic Getaway with Private Hot Tub near Warren Dunes State Park, Michigan

Union Pier, MI, United States

$341
Blocks to Town, Game Room, Firepit, Huge Backyard Photo

Blocks to Town, Game Room, Firepit, Huge Backyard

New Buffalo, MI, United States

10.0
$245

Useful insights on New Buffalo vacation rentals

Get a quick overview on price and accommodation trends for your visit in New Buffalo

Lowest Vacation Rental Price

$113

Average Length of Stay

2 days
The cheapest price for a room in New Buffalo found in the last 7 days is $113/night. This rate is available with Anchors Away.
On average, people stay for 2 days when lodging at vacation rentals in New Buffalo. The average accommodation price for 2 days in New Buffalo in the past week is $448.

When to book a vacation rental in New Buffalo

Check out the information below to find the best deal on a vacation rental in New Buffalo
Low SeasonMaycheapest month to stay
High SeasonAugustmost expensive time to stay
66%expected price decrease
61%expected price increase

Price

$151 - $1,168

Cheapest day of weekTuesdayis the cheapest day of the week to book
Highest day of weekFridayis the most expensive day of the week to book
$255
$448

Information about staying in New Buffalo

Read these important travel tips before booking a vacation rental in New Buffalo

How long do people typically book vacation apartments for in New Buffalo?

About 2 nights is the most common choice for those booking vacation apartment rentals in New Buffalo.

When is the best time to book a vacation rental in New Buffalo?

May is typically when New Buffalo vacation apartment and rental property prices are at their lowest, with prices around 67% lower than the New Buffalo peak season.

How many operators does momondo search for hotels in New Buffalo?

As of April 2025, there are 316 operators available to choose from for hotels in New Buffalo.

When did momondo last update prices for hotels in New Buffalo?

Prices for hotels in New Buffalo are updated daily.

Save money when you book vacation rentals with momondo

Best deals on hotels

Best deals on hotels

See deals from 3M+ hotels and accommodations in one place.

Free cancellation

Free cancellation

Use our filter to find stays with free cancellation.

Millions of reviews

Millions of reviews

Check ratings based on millions of real guest reviews.

Price Alerts

Price Alerts

Not ready to book? to track prices.

An easier way to manage your New Buffalo trip

We make it super easy to schedule, organize and travel with friends or family. Trips is free — and available to use no matter where you book.
Start using Trips
Find my bookings

Get notified when prices go down

Daily price changes in your inbox - only with Price Alerts.
mié. 5/7
jue. 5/8
By creating a price alert you accept our terms of use and privacy policy.

Find better results for your stay in New Buffalo