How does Amara Cay Resort compare to other 4 star hotels in Islamorada?

In Islamorada, 4 star hotels have average nightly rates of $319. Amara Cay Resort is $154 cheaper than the city average at just $165/night. Visit the hotel page for more details.

Is Amara Cay Resort pet-friendly?

Pets are allowed at Amara Cay Resort. Visit the hotel page for more details.

Are there food options at Amara Cay Resort?

Yes, Amara Cay Resort does have a restaurant where you can sit down to eat or take food to go. There are also many other quality food options in Islamorada for those looking for something different. If you are staying at Amara Cay Resort, you are more than welcome to order food through the hotel’s room service menu. Visit the hotel page for more details.

Does Amara Cay Resort have a pool?

Yes. Many momondo users traveling to Islamorada specifically look for hotels with a pool. Amara Cay Resort may have rules and guidelines for using the pool, so be sure to ask the front desk about things like pool hours. Visit the hotel page for more details.

How close is Amara Cay Resort to Islamorada city center?

Amara Cay Resort is just 2.4 mi away from Islamorada city center. The closest landmark to the center of Islamorada is Theater of the Sea, which is very accessible to Amara Cay Resort guests. Visit the hotel page for more details.

What is the phone number for Amara Cay Resort?

The best contact number for Amara Cay Resort is +1 305 664 0073 . Visit the hotel page for more details.

Does Amara Cay Resort have Wi-Fi available?

Yes, Amara Cay Resort has Wi-Fi available to hotel guests. Visit the hotel page for more details.

Is there a gym or fitness center available to guests at Amara Cay Resort?

There is a fitness center available to Amara Cay Resort guests. Visit the hotel page for more details.

What time is check-out for Amara Cay Resort?

You can plan to arrive after 4:00 PM for checking in. Check-out time is 11:00 AM. We advise notifying the front desk of any requests as early as possible. Visit the hotel page for more details.

How much is a room at Amara Cay Resort?

The cheapest deals found start from only $153 per night. The average rate for rooms at Amara Cay Resort is currently around $305/night. Enter your dates in the form above to see more. Visit the hotel page for more details.

How many operators does momondo search for hotels in Islamorada?

There are 773 operators available for hotels in Islamorada as of September 2025. Visit the hotel page for more details.

When did momondo last update prices for hotels in Islamorada?

Prices for hotels in Islamorada refresh daily. Visit the hotel page for more details.

Amara Cay Resort in Islamorada, the United States from $184: Deals, Reviews, Photos

4 stars

80001 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, FL 33036

+1 305 664 0073

8.2

Very good

1,220 verified ratings

$184

Rate

rate per night

About Amara Cay Resort, Islamorada

Featuring free Wi-Fi, a swimming pool and a private beach, Amara Cay Resort is located in Islamorada and is a brief stroll from Bud n' Mary's Fishing Marina and Key Dives. It also offers a sun deck, a 24-hour reception and an express check-in and check-out feature. The hotel has 110 rooms and has been recently refurbished. Those staying at the property have access to a terrace and a BBQ area. Rooms have a private bathroom, a seating area and a flat-screen TV. They are also equipped with ironing facilities, a shower and a hair dryer. Amara Cay Resort has its own on-site restaurant, perfect for those who wish to dine in. The on-site bar provides a relaxing setting for an evening drink. The hotel offers parking and is a five-minute car trip from Hurricane Monument, Island Body & Sol Spa and Blu Bamboo Salon and Day Spa. Key Largo and Marathon are also just a brief car ride from the property.

Amara Cay Resort photos

Amara Cay Resort room price & deals

Mon 9/22

Tue 9/23

Queen room

2 queen beds

$293

nightly with fees

2 queen beds

$296

nightly with fees

2 queen beds

$305

nightly with fees

King room

bed type unknown

$241

nightly with fees

1 king bed

$245

nightly with fees

bed type unknown

$254

nightly with fees

Standard room

bed type unknown

$184

nightly with fees

bed type unknown

$217

nightly with fees

1 king bed

$222

nightly with fees

Double room

1 king bed

$200

nightly with fees

1 twin bed

$241

nightly with fees

bed type unknown

$305

nightly with fees

*Total includes estimated local taxes & fees payable on check out.

Prices are based on 1 night, including fees but not including taxes.

Resort Amenities & Facilities

Private beach
Water sport facilities (on site)
Snorkeling
Outdoor pool
Fitness center
Restaurant
Bar/Lounge
Room service
Bicycle rental
Coffee machine

Things to do

Gift shop
Eco tourism
Bicycle rental
Fishing
Cycling
Diving
Snorkeling
Water sport facilities (on site)

Accessibility and suitability

Non-smoking rooms available
Pets allowed on request. Charges may apply.
Increased accessibility
Elevator
Hypoallergenic
Designated smoking area

Dining

Special diet menus (on request)
Snack bar
Restaurant
Bar/Lounge
Refrigerator
Coffee machine

Outdoor

Terrace/Patio
Beach towels
Balcony
Private beach
Garden

Services and conveniences

Meeting/Banquet facilities
Mini-market on site
Room service
Express check-out
24hr front desk

Basics

Wi-Fi available in all areas
Internet
Wi-Fi
Smoke alarms
Air-conditioned

Parking and transportation

Parking
Parking (surcharge)
Shuttle service
Private parking

Media and entertainment

Flat-screen TV
Shared lounge/TV area
Cable or satellite TV
TV

General

Family rooms
Sea view
Telephone
Storage available

Pool

Pool bar
Heated pool
Outdoor pool
Pool with a view

Bathroom

Hairdryer
Bathrobe
Private bathroom

Laundry

Laundry facilities
Iron and ironing board

Workspace

Fax/photocopying
Desk

Family friendly

Kids meals

Fitness

Fitness center

Amara Cay Resort Reviews

8.2

Very good1,220 verified ratings

Pros +

Highly recommend Amara Cay! (in 7 reviews)
Resort spotless Rooms great. (in 24 reviews)
The hotel is modern and stylish (in 19 reviews)

Cons -

I didn’t like the bathroom. (in 15 reviews)
The room was not clean. (in 48 reviews)
Resort fee should be optional. (in 13 reviews)

Amara Cay Resort room booking info

Value for money

7.5

Location rating

9.0

Distance to city center

2.4 mi

Check in/Check out

Check in anytime after 4:00 PM, check out anytime before 11:00 AM

Cancellation/prepayment

Cancellation/prepayment policies vary by room type and provider.

Frequently asked questions

How does Amara Cay Resort compare to other 4 star hotels in Islamorada?
In Islamorada, 4 star hotels have average nightly rates of $319. Amara Cay Resort is $154 cheaper than the city average at just $165/night.
Is Amara Cay Resort pet-friendly?
Pets are allowed at Amara Cay Resort.
Are there food options at Amara Cay Resort?
Yes, Amara Cay Resort does have a restaurant where you can sit down to eat or take food to go. There are also many other quality food options in Islamorada for those looking for something different. If you are staying at Amara Cay Resort, you are more than welcome to order food through the hotel’s room service menu.
Does Amara Cay Resort have a pool?
Yes. Many momondo users traveling to Islamorada specifically look for hotels with a pool. Amara Cay Resort may have rules and guidelines for using the pool, so be sure to ask the front desk about things like pool hours.
How close is Amara Cay Resort to Islamorada city center?
Amara Cay Resort is just 2.4 mi away from Islamorada city center. The closest landmark to the center of Islamorada is Theater of the Sea, which is very accessible to Amara Cay Resort guests.
What is the phone number for Amara Cay Resort?
The best contact number for Amara Cay Resort is +1 305 664 0073.
Does Amara Cay Resort have Wi-Fi available?
Yes, Amara Cay Resort has Wi-Fi available to hotel guests.
Is there a gym or fitness center available to guests at Amara Cay Resort?
There is a fitness center available to Amara Cay Resort guests.
What time is check-out for Amara Cay Resort?
You can plan to arrive after 4:00 PM for checking in. Check-out time is 11:00 AM. We advise notifying the front desk of any requests as early as possible.
How much is a room at Amara Cay Resort?
The cheapest deals found start from only $153 per night. The average rate for rooms at Amara Cay Resort is currently around $305/night. Enter your dates in the form above to see more.
How many operators does momondo search for hotels in Islamorada?
There are 773 operators available for hotels in Islamorada as of September 2025.
When did momondo last update prices for hotels in Islamorada?
Prices for hotels in Islamorada refresh daily.