Car rentals in Downtown, Key West

You can expect to spend around $5 per day on average on a rental car in Downtown. Depending on what neighborhood you plan to visit, daily rental prices may be as low as $5 per day or as high as $10 per day which is a 50% difference.

At the moment, Downtown’s cheapest rental car company is Avis, where users have found prices for as low as $5/day. You may also consider renting from Advantage or CarWiz which are also some of the cheapest rental companies in the neighborhood. Users have recently found prices at Advantage for $5/day and $5/day from CarWiz.

The cheapest neighborhood to rent a car when in Key West is New Town. On average, the daily cost to rent a car in New Town is $28 from Hertz. Another affordable neighborhood to rent a car in is Golf Club, where Budget has an average price of $59 per day.

Prices for cars in Downtown are updated daily.

There are 10 operators available for cars in Downtown as of June 2025.

The minimum age for drivers varies by country, including Downtown. In many EU countries drivers must be 18 years old. As a rule, you’ll need to be 21 to hire a car abroad, and a young driver surcharge may be applied if you are under 25. We recommend reading through the policy of your chosen rental company before booking.

All drivers must have a valid full driving license when renting a car in Downtown. If the license is written in a different language from the country of rental, an International Driving Permit may be required to avoid the risk of potential fines. If you're renting a car overseas, you may also need to provide proof of return travel and accommodation information during your stay. It is always advisable to check with the individual rental company you're booking with.