Car rentals in New Town, Key West

Renting a car in New Town will cost, on average, $51 per day. Keep in mind that daily rental prices fluctuate based on a variety of factors. For example, momondo users recently found New Town car rental prices for as much as $90 per day and as little as $32 per day.

Hertz is the cheapest rental car company in New Town according to our data from the past 72 hours. You can find prices for as low as $32 per day from Hertz. Enterprise Rent-A-Car is another affordable rental company, with prices recently found for as low as $38 per day. You should also consider Alamo, which recently had rental prices for $46 per day.

Hertz is considered the best car rental company in New Town based on our data - 33 reviews have given them an average customer satisfaction score of 5.6 out of 10.

Although there are plenty of other rental car types to choose from, the most popular type for a trip to New Town are SUV sized cars. 24% of our users chose this rental type and found prices for $109/day on average.

At the moment, the cheapest neighborhoods to rent a car in Key West are Golf Club and Mid Town East from Budget and Enterprise Rent-A-Car, respectively. Budget in Golf Club has average rental rates of $46/day while Enterprise Rent-A-Car in Mid Town East offers rentals for $75/day on average.

The majority of momondo users will rent a car in New Town for 2 days at an average cost of $75 per day. Renting for 1 week will cost a total of $539, while renting for just the weekend will cost $195 in total. You can also rent a car for a month or longer if need be - according to our data, renting a car for a month in New Town costs, on average, $1,726 total.

The best time to rent a car in New Town is in the month of September, when prices are $68/day on average. July is often the most expensive month to rent a car when average prices are $81/day. However, no matter what month you plan to visit New Town, it’s recommended that you book your rental around 16 days out for the best possible price.

Prices for cars in New Town are refreshed on a daily basis.

The number of operators available for cars in New Town is 11 as of April 2025.

The minimum age for drivers varies by country, including New Town. In many EU countries drivers must be 18 years old. As a rule, you’ll need to be 21 to hire a car abroad, and a young driver surcharge may be applied if you are under 25. We recommend reading through the policy of your chosen rental company before booking.

All drivers must have a valid full driving license when renting a car in New Town. If the license is written in a different language from the country of rental, an International Driving Permit may be required to avoid the risk of potential fines. If you're renting a car overseas, you may also need to provide proof of return travel and accommodation information during your stay. It is always advisable to check with the individual rental company you're booking with.