Find and compare great deals on Thrifty rental cars at New York LaGuardia Airport
Same drop-off
Thrifty car rental deals at New York LaGuardia Airport
Find your perfect rental car on momondo
Enter your travel dates to find the best prices.
Small
Medium
Large
SUV
Small cars
$47 - $132
All Car Types
$47 - $113
The best time to rent a small car car from Thrifty at New York LaGuardia airport is in December when prices are $47 per day on average. $47 per day is 50% lower than the $93 average yearly price for a Thrifty small car rental at New York LaGuardia airport. While December may be the cheapest month to rent a small car car from Thrifty at New York LaGuardia airport, September is the most expensive. However, you may still be able to find great deals in September on small car rental vehicles from Thrifty depending on what day you book.
The best time to rent a medium car car from Thrifty at New York LaGuardia airport is in April when prices are $66 per day on average. $66 per day is 26% lower than the $89 average yearly price for a Thrifty medium car rental at New York LaGuardia airport. While April may be the cheapest month to rent a medium car car from Thrifty at New York LaGuardia airport, August is the most expensive. However, you may still be able to find great deals in August on medium car rental vehicles from Thrifty depending on what day you book.
The best time to rent a large car car from Thrifty at New York LaGuardia airport is in April when prices are $93 per day on average. $93 per day is 18% lower than the $114 average yearly price for a Thrifty large car rental at New York LaGuardia airport. While April may be the cheapest month to rent a large car car from Thrifty at New York LaGuardia airport, May is the most expensive. However, you may still be able to find great deals in May on large car rental vehicles from Thrifty depending on what day you book.
The best time to rent a SUV car from Thrifty at New York LaGuardia airport is in December when prices are $47 per day on average. $47 per day is 45% lower than the $85 average yearly price for a Thrifty SUV rental at New York LaGuardia airport. While December may be the cheapest month to rent a SUV car from Thrifty at New York LaGuardia airport, June is the most expensive. However, you may still be able to find great deals in June on SUV rental vehicles from Thrifty depending on what day you book.
Thrifty car rentals near New York LaGuardia Airport
Below you will find information for every Thrifty rental car location near New York LaGuardia Airport, including address and phone number
View Thrifty Locations near New York LaGuardia Airport
Thrifty reviews
5.2
Fair48 verified ratings
Sort by:
Date
6.0 Okay
Anonymous, May 2026
They don't inform you ahead nor on morning that if you use a debit card they hold back $500.00 deposit
2.0 Poor
Anonymous, May 2026
ended up not being able to claim this booking because it was for international driver even though it never told me that, had to go to another company and book last minute
2.0 Poor
M, Apr 2026
I completed all of the paperwork online in advance and it took an hour and ten minutes to get the car. Unacceptable. The airport agent , Michelle, changed my return time to an hour later. When I returned it, Thrifty sent me an additional bill which I was able to get resolved thru the customer service phone number. However, when I returned the car, there was confusion because the sign at the end of the return aisle said to return the key to the drop box at the kiosk and when I did so the agent at the kiosk told me to drive back around to him but the car was parked at the end of the return aisle where the sign was. After I gave him the keys another employee told me to give Him the keys. Poor system.
10.0 Wonderful
Anonymous, Mar 2026
super easy
2.0 Poor
Kristen, Mar 2026
I chose Thrifty because I thought they would be a reliable company. Instead they turned out to be the biggest scammers and most costly option. I reserved the rental bc it said my total price would be $36 for 2 days. When I arrived to receive my rental, it ended up being over double the price. Usually we are given the option to opt in or out for insurance. They did not give me this option and insisted I be charged for insurance. To make matters worse, I was given a very old car.. I requested for it to be switched which they accommodated for. When I checked out the car, I was charged nearly $400 for damages.. for a small crack in the bumper. What was the point of me paying for insurance? What was supposed to be a $36 purchase ended up being over $500. A true nightmare!!! I will never be renting from Thrifty again!!! Worst company ever.
FAQs about renting a car from Thrifty at New York LaGuardia Airport
How much does it cost to rent a car from Thrifty at New York LaGuardia airport?
On average a hire car from Thrifty at New York LaGuardia airport costs $77 per day. However, you might be able to find rental car deals as low as $24 per day which is a 91% difference from the highest price per day at $244.
What is the most popular rental car type from Thrifty at New York LaGuardia airport?
The most popular type of cars to rent from Thrifty at New York LaGuardia airport are SUV cars. This type of car costs $88 per day on average. 35% of users prefer to rent SUV cars from Thrifty at New York LaGuardia airport due to price, availability, and their planned activities.
Where can I find Thrifty car rentals at New York LaGuardia airport?
45-01 20th Avenue is the closest Thrifty hire car location to New York LaGuardia airport. The telephone number for this location is +1 718 779 7456
Does Thrifty offer shuttle or airport pick-up services from New York LaGuardia airport (LGA)?
Yes, Thrifty offers pick-up services from New York LaGuardia airport (LGA).
An easier way to manage your New York trip
We make it super easy to schedule, organize and travel with friends or family. Trips is free — and available to use no matter where you book.
This site uses cookies and other tracking technologies for essential, functional, analytical, and advertising purposes. By using the site, you agree to our Terms & Conditions and our Privacy Policy.
For more information about how we process your information, please see our Privacy Policy.
We value your privacy
momondo and its partners wish to use cookies or similar technologies to store and/or access information on and about your device and process personal data such as your IP address, device identifiers etc., in order to improve your experience on the site, to analyze navigation, to offer and measure personalized advertising, and to facilitate sharing on social networks. We also allow the use of third-party cookies (including those from our advertising partners) on our sites.
By clicking 'Accept', you consent to your data being processed by 0 vendors on this web site for the purposes described in this notice. You can review the vendors and their individual processing purposes on the .
To review individual processing purposes and cookie categories, please click ’Select individual purposes’. You can review your choices and withdraw your consent at any time by clicking the ’Privacy Preferences’ link in the page side navigation.