Useful insights to help you book the perfect rental car in Bay Shore
Companies
Other Information
What car do most people rent in Bay Shore?
When renting a car in Bay Shore, most of our users will opt for the Toyota RAV4 at $111/day on average. The second most popular is the Hyundai Venue car rental for an average of $71/day. Our users have found Toyota RAV4 rentals in Bay Shore for as low as $45/day and Hyundai Venue rentals for as low as $38/day.
Bay Shore, New York State car rental deals found on momondo
Find the rental car in Bay Shore that's right for you
Small cars
$43 - $163
All Car Types
$58 - $136
The average price of a small car rental in Bay Shore, the United States is $69. The cheapest time to rent a small car in Bay Shore, the United States is in September. The price is 38% lower than the rest of the year at just $43 per day. A small car rental is typically 14% less expensive than the average rental car in Bay Shore. The average price of a vehicle rental in Bay Shore can vary based on a number of factors including supply, popularity of the vehicle, and how far out you book your rental car. Below are the best prices for Bay Shore small car rentals found on momondo in the past week.
The average price of a medium car rental in Bay Shore, the United States is $74. The cheapest time to rent a medium car in Bay Shore, the United States is in May. The price is 49% lower than the rest of the year at just $38 per day. A medium car rental is typically 8% less expensive than the average rental car in Bay Shore. The average price of a vehicle rental in Bay Shore can vary based on a number of factors including supply, popularity of the vehicle, and how far out you book your rental car. Below are the best prices for Bay Shore medium car rentals found on momondo in the past week.
The average price of a large car rental in Bay Shore, the United States is $95. The cheapest time to rent a large car in Bay Shore, the United States is in October. The price is 36% lower than the rest of the year at just $61 per day. A large car rental is typically 16% more expensive than the average rental car in Bay Shore. The average price of a vehicle rental in Bay Shore can vary based on a number of factors including supply, popularity of the vehicle, and how far out you book your rental car. Below are the best prices for Bay Shore large car rentals found on momondo in the past week.
The average price of a SUV rental in Bay Shore, the United States is $81. The cheapest time to rent a SUV in Bay Shore, the United States is in May. The price is 29% lower than the rest of the year at just $59 per day. A SUV rental is typically 3% more expensive than the average rental car in Bay Shore. The average price of a vehicle rental in Bay Shore can vary based on a number of factors including supply, popularity of the vehicle, and how far out you book your rental car. Below are the best prices for Bay Shore SUV rentals found on momondo in the past week.
The average price of a van rental in Bay Shore, the United States is $103. The cheapest time to rent a van in Bay Shore, the United States is in December. The price is 38% lower than the rest of the year at just $65 per day. A van rental is typically 24% more expensive than the average rental car in Bay Shore. The average price of a vehicle rental in Bay Shore can vary based on a number of factors including supply, popularity of the vehicle, and how far out you book your rental car. Below are the best prices for Bay Shore van rentals found on momondo in the past week.
The average price of a luxury car rental in Bay Shore, the United States is $109. The cheapest time to rent a luxury car in Bay Shore, the United States is in January. The price is 28% lower than the rest of the year at just $79 per day. A luxury car rental is typically 27% more expensive than the average rental car in Bay Shore. The average price of a vehicle rental in Bay Shore can vary based on a number of factors including supply, popularity of the vehicle, and how far out you book your rental car. Below are the best prices for Bay Shore luxury car rentals found on momondo in the past week.
Got into rental car and a terrible smell of cigarett, opened windows and drove away only to return it and asked for another vehicle. Was given another and used it for the whole time with no problems and will continue to book with them. The agent was very apoligetic and called them for a copy of changed vehicle, which they sent to my email. I had previously booked with this agent and had no problems with the Kia Forte, which eventually purchased when returned from my trip. Your pricing for the rental was so much lower than through other websites that I have booked on and also plan to continue through Kayak.
7.9
Good|Jul 2021
Car was very clean!! However, Front desk gentleman was not cordial, did not introduce himself nor welcomed me He went straight to asking me "license and credit card" The rear tire was low on air. I did receive a 10% off. I waited for him, and he didn't even apologize for the delay.
The car was not ready at the time I requested it. I needed to wait for the interior to be cleaned then was asked to go to the car wash myself and get the car washed. Setting my family and I back behind schedule, once we were able to get on the road the check engine light came on and remained on the entirety of our trip. This experience was less than acceptable.
The price of renting the car from the hotel instead of the airport was much cheaper. Only thing was I had to call a number when I got to the hotel bc no agent was waiting for me. Was very accommodating when she arrived first car did not have power seats and I couldn’t see over steering wheel so she switched cars to a Camry which did and was a great car. Also said I could bring back to airport and extended the return time.
10.0
Wonderful|Jul 2021
I loved my last minute upgrade that the company provided. Very easy check in and check out process.
1 out of 1
View Budget Locations in Bay Shore
Quick facts about car rentals in Bay Shore
Get the overview on great rental deals, popular car rental companies, and best car types for your visit in Bay Shore
Most Popular Agency
Budget
Popular Car Types
Economy, Full-size, Intermediate
Cheapest Rental Car
$47
Most Popular Model
Toyota RAV4
The most popular Bay Shore car rental agency found on momondo this month is Budget. Other top choices for car rental companies are Turo and Enterprise Rent-A-Car
The following car types were offered at rental car companies in Bay Shore in the past 72 hours: Economy, Full-size, Intermediate.
The lowest price for a rental car in Bay Shore is $47/day. For this area, you can expect average prices starting from $70/day.
The most popular car model to rent in Bay Shore in the past 7 days is the Toyota RAV4. Our users also prefer the Hyundai Venue as an alternative.
Learn everything there is to know about renting a car in Bay Shore so you can be properly prepared for your next trip
Is there a fee to cancel my Bay Shore, New York car rental?
In most cases, there is no fee when you cancel your Bay Shore car rental. You can check to see whether or not your preferred car rental company in Bay Shore offers free cancellation when booking with momondo.
What is the speed limit in Bay Shore, New York?
25 mph is the city speed limit for Bay Shore, which also applies to surrounding towns and other urban centers. The suburban speed limit and the speed limit for highways around Bay Shore are 75 mph and 75 mph, respectively. If you rent a car in Bay Shore, be aware that these speed limits may be strictly enforced.
What car rental company has the Toyota RAV4 in Bay Shore?
If you’re interested in renting the Toyota RAV4 in Bay Shore, then Budget is the most popular car rental company in the city that offers this vehicle (as well as other similar SUV rentals). Toyota RAV4 rentals in Bay Shore from Budget are $84 per day on average.
Is the weather in Bay Shore similar to the rest of New York?
If you’re looking for a Bay Shore rental car for a road trip to the surrounding areas during the month of December it’s important to know that the rest of New York typically has a temperature of 32 °F and will usually expect 3.2″ of precipitation.
When did momondo last update prices for cars in Bay Shore?
Prices for cars in Bay Shore are updated daily.
How many operators does momondo search for cars in Bay Shore?
As of December 2025, there are 13 operators available to choose from for cars in Bay Shore.
How old do you have to be to hire a car in Bay Shore?
The minimum age for drivers varies by country, including Bay Shore. In numerous EU countries, drivers must be 18 years old. To rent a car overseas, you'll generally need to be at least 21, and if you're under 25, a young driver surcharge may be applied. We advise that you read the policy of your chosen rental company before making a reservation.
What documentation or ID do you need to rent a car in Bay Shore?
When renting a car in Bay Shore, all drivers must present a full valid driving license. An International Driving Permit is required if the driving license is written in a language different to that of the country of rental and may be necessary to avoid the risk of potential fines. If you are renting abroad, you may also need to provide proof of return travel and accommodation information during your stay. We always recommend checking with the individual rental company you are booking with.
Traveling to a place near Bay Shore?
Rent a car at Bay Shore if you plan to visit one of these locations
Seaside Heights
Ocean Grove
Pocono Manor
Lakeville
Galloway
Fire Island
Rhinebeck
West Long Branch
Hyde Park
Seaside Park
Carlstadt
Woodbury
Liberty
Islandia
Avenel
Central Valley
Kenilworth
Montgomery
Clark
Orangeburg
Why use momondo?
Why should I use momondo to book a car rental in Bay Shore?
Choosing momondo to search for rental cars in Bay Shore makes sense because it is quick and free of charge. We find all the rental car prices and policies, you simply choose what works best for you and your trip.
How does momondo help me find the best car rental deal in Bay Shore?
Filtering is how momondo helps you find a great rental car in Bay Shore. Narrow your search using price and map features as well as filtering by fuel or mileage policies amongst many other filters available.
Does momondo show car rental deals in Bay Shore with free cancellation?
Yes, whether it is for cars in Bay Shore or elsewhere, momondo allows you to filter specifically for policies that offer free cancellation.
Can I rent a car with a fair fuel policy in Bay Shore on momondo?
Yes, momondo has a filter for fair fuel policies on car rentals in Bay Shore.
Can I find a car rental in Bay Shore which offers enhanced cleaning on momondo?
Yes, momondo can show you specific deals which include enhanced cleaning on car rentals in Bay Shore.
Can I search for rental cars in Bay Shore with unlimited mileage on momondo?
Absolutely. You can specifically filter for rental car deals in Bay Shore with unlimited mileage on momondo.
An easier way to manage your Bay Shore trip
We make it super easy to schedule, organize and travel with friends or family. Trips is free — and available to use no matter where you book.
This site uses cookies and other tracking technologies for essential, functional, analytical, and advertising purposes. By using the site, you agree to our Terms & Conditions and our Privacy Policy.
For more information about how we process your information, please see our Privacy Policy.
We value your privacy
momondo and its partners wish to use cookies or similar technologies to store and/or access information on and about your device and process personal data such as your IP address, device identifiers etc., in order to improve your experience on the site, to analyze navigation, to offer and measure personalized advertising, and to facilitate sharing on social networks. We also allow the use of third-party cookies (including those from our advertising partners) on our sites.
By clicking 'Accept', you consent to your data being processed by 0 vendors on this web site for the purposes described in this notice. You can review the vendors and their individual processing purposes on the .
To review individual processing purposes and cookie categories, please click ’Select individual purposes’. You can review your choices and withdraw your consent at any time by clicking the ’Privacy Preferences’ link in the page side navigation.