Useful insights to help you book the perfect rental car in Shirley
Companies
Other Information
What car do most people rent in Shirley?
Renting the Toyota RAV4 in Shirley is the most popular car rental among momondo users, followed by renting the Chrysler Pacifica. Our users have seen Toyota RAV4 deals in Shirley for $124 per day on average, and as cheap as $87 per day. It’s an average of $73 per day to rent the Chrysler Pacifica in Shirley, though you may find prices as low as $70 per day.
Shirley, New York State car rental deals found on momondo
Find the rental car in Shirley that's right for you
Small cars
$55 - $108
All Car Types
$69 - $140
The average price of a small car rental in Shirley, the United States is $71. The cheapest time to rent a small car in Shirley, the United States is in March. The price is 24% lower than the rest of the year at just $55 per day. A small car rental is typically 23% less expensive than the average rental car in Shirley. The average price of a vehicle rental in Shirley can vary based on a number of factors including supply, popularity of the vehicle, and how far out you book your rental car.
The average price of a medium car rental in Shirley, the United States is $83. The cheapest time to rent a medium car in Shirley, the United States is in February. The price is 40% lower than the rest of the year at just $51 per day. A medium car rental is typically 10% less expensive than the average rental car in Shirley. The average price of a vehicle rental in Shirley can vary based on a number of factors including supply, popularity of the vehicle, and how far out you book your rental car. Below are the best prices for Shirley medium car rentals found on momondo in the past week.
The average price of a large car rental in Shirley, the United States is $111. The cheapest time to rent a large car in Shirley, the United States is in September. The price is 33% lower than the rest of the year at just $75 per day. A large car rental is typically 17% more expensive than the average rental car in Shirley. The average price of a vehicle rental in Shirley can vary based on a number of factors including supply, popularity of the vehicle, and how far out you book your rental car. Below are the best prices for Shirley large car rentals found on momondo in the past week.
The average price of a SUV rental in Shirley, the United States is $96. The cheapest time to rent a SUV in Shirley, the United States is in February. The price is 33% lower than the rest of the year at just $65 per day. A SUV rental is typically 5% more expensive than the average rental car in Shirley. The average price of a vehicle rental in Shirley can vary based on a number of factors including supply, popularity of the vehicle, and how far out you book your rental car. Below are the best prices for Shirley SUV rentals found on momondo in the past week.
The average price of a van rental in Shirley, the United States is $121. The cheapest time to rent a van in Shirley, the United States is in March. The price is 43% lower than the rest of the year at just $69 per day. A van rental is typically 24% more expensive than the average rental car in Shirley. The average price of a vehicle rental in Shirley can vary based on a number of factors including supply, popularity of the vehicle, and how far out you book your rental car.
The average price of a luxury car rental in Shirley, the United States is $116. The cheapest time to rent a luxury car in Shirley, the United States is in October. The price is 41% lower than the rest of the year at just $70 per day. A luxury car rental is typically 21% more expensive than the average rental car in Shirley. The average price of a vehicle rental in Shirley can vary based on a number of factors including supply, popularity of the vehicle, and how far out you book your rental car. Below are the best prices for Shirley luxury car rentals found on momondo in the past week.
Shirley car rental directory
All major car rental suppliers in Shirley, New York State
Car was not available when I got there . I was left stranded with no vehicle they siad this happens when you rent online , best we can do is call you when a vehicle is available. It's been 4 days no call, no concern, terrible customer service
10.0
Wonderful|Jan 2022
Great local service Clean car fast pickup They even let me leave my car in their lot for the rental time
Car smelled. They did not have a different one at pick up. Return was a catastrophe. Location that was designated to be opened was not. Sign at key drop off said renter responsible for time until they signed it in. The lady on the phone at Hertz was impossibly useless and supervisor never returned my call. When I went back on the following day everything worked out all right but the whole experience was nothing but annoying.
2.0
Poor|Apr 2022
Personal, cleanliness, site Will be great if give us the car we requested,
8.0
Very good|Mar 2022
Price was good. Car was dirty with dents and a burn hole on drivers seat. Pick up and drop off were easy once we found the hotel to drop off.
10.0
Wonderful|Feb 2022
Cleaner outside…but it is winter!
1.9
Poor|Aug 2021
The car drove fine and was comfortable enough for being so small, but had not been cleaned and was previously driven by someone smoking so that it smelled like cigarettes the entire time I had it. I had to wipe crumbs and dust off the dash and steering wheel and use windex and paper towels on the inside windshield and mirrors so that I could see. I think someone tried wiping with a dirty rag or something before me. The rental office shares the lot with a tow company and auto shop that made it hard to get the car out. When I showed up to return the car, they had locked the door and put a sign saying I had to drop off at a different location almost 30 minutes away. Luckily the agent I spoke said she could come to get the car where I was since I could not take it 30 minutes away.
2.0
Poor|Jun 2021
I got there to get told I couldn't have a car because I didn't have a credit card I only needed a day I ask if we could work something out and they just said no sorry not even trying so I was to q different place I able to use my bank card to rent a car.
the car was dirty, smelled like armpit juice. the windsheild i could not see out of, the defroster didnt work . good luck for the next driver
1 out of 1
View Budget Locations in Shirley
Quick facts about car rentals in Shirley
Get the overview on great rental deals, popular car rental companies, and best car types for your visit in Shirley
Most Popular Agency
Turo
Cheapest Rental Car
$61
Most Popular Model
Toyota RAV4
The most popular Shirley car rental agency found on momondo this month is Turo. Other top choices for car rental companies are Enterprise Rent-A-Car and Budget
The lowest price for a rental car in Shirley is $61/day. For this area, you can expect average prices starting from $102/day.
The most popular car model to rent in Shirley in the past 7 days is the Toyota RAV4. Our users also prefer the Chrysler Pacifica as an alternative.
Learn everything there is to know about renting a car in Shirley so you can be properly prepared for your next trip
How much will it cost to rent a car in Shirley, New York in September?
$87 is the cost of a weekend car rental in Shirley for September, with cheap deals starting as low as $87. Deals are a little different for a week-long rental - starting at around $0, with an average price of $0.
Is there a fee to cancel my Shirley, New York car rental?
The majority of the Shirley car rental agencies that we partner with do not have a cancellation fee. This means that if your plans change unexpectedly, many car rental centers in Shirley such as Enterprise Rent-A-Car, Avis, and Budget often offer cancellation free of charge based on when you booked.
What is the speed limit in Shirley, New York?
25 mph is the city speed limit for Shirley, which also applies to surrounding towns and other urban centers. The suburban speed limit and the speed limit for highways around Shirley are 75 mph and 75 mph, respectively. If you rent a car in Shirley, be aware that these speed limits may be strictly enforced.
What car rental company has the Toyota RAV4 in Shirley?
Budget has Toyota RAV4 rentals available in Shirley for $124/day on average. Availability for the Toyota RAV4 rental in Shirley may vary, so try not to schedule your car rental last-minute.
Is the weather in Shirley similar to the rest of New York?
Travelers looking to leave from Shirley on a road trip around New York or the surrounding areas during the month of August should expect temperatures around 69.8 °F and about 3.7″ of possible rain through the month.
When did momondo last update prices for cars in Shirley?
Prices for cars in Shirley are updated daily.
How many operators does momondo search for cars in Shirley?
The number of operators available for cars in Shirley is 11 as of August 2025.
How old do you have to be to hire a car in Shirley?
The minimum age for drivers varies by country, including Shirley. In numerous EU countries, drivers must be 18 years old. To rent a car overseas, you'll generally need to be at least 21, and if you're under 25, a young driver surcharge may be applied. We advise that you read the policy of your chosen rental company before making a reservation.
What documentation or ID do you need to rent a car in Shirley?
To rent a car in Shirley, all drivers must present a valid full driving license. If the license is written in a language other than the language of the country of rental, an International Driving Permit may be required to avoid the risk of potential fines. If you're renting a car abroad, you may also need to provide evidence of your return travel and accommodation information during your stay. We always recommend that you verify with the specific rental company you're booking with.
Traveling to a place near Shirley?
Rent a car at Shirley if you plan to visit one of these locations
Seaside Heights
Pocono Manor
Ocean Grove
Lakeville
Galloway
Fire Island
Rhinebeck
West Long Branch
Seaside Park
Hyde Park
Woodbury
Islandia
Carlstadt
Liberty
Clark
Avenel
Montgomery
Central Valley
Chester
Orangeburg
Why use momondo?
Why should I use momondo to book a car rental in Shirley?
momondo finds and compares thousands of car rental websites to provide you with the best selection of policies and car rentals in Shirley. Finding a rental car is quick and free of charge, so using momondo for your booking makes sense.
How does momondo help me find the best car rental deal in Shirley?
momondo makes it easier for you to find great car rentals in Shirley, by allowing you to refine your search with numerous filtering options. You can narrow your selection by looking at price, car type, location and more.
Does momondo show car rental deals in Shirley with free cancellation?
Free cancellation is a policy that can be filtered on momondo car rental searches for Shirley and all other locations. Availability may vary by location.
Can I rent a car with a fair fuel policy in Shirley on momondo?
Absolutely! momondo offers this feature when searching for a rental car in Shirley.
Can I find a car rental in Shirley which offers enhanced cleaning on momondo?
You certainly can. momondo has a dedicated filter for enhanced cleaning services for all car rental locations including Shirley.
Can I search for rental cars in Shirley with unlimited mileage on momondo?
Absolutely. You can specifically filter for rental car deals in Shirley with unlimited mileage on momondo.
An easier way to manage your Shirley trip
We make it super easy to schedule, organize and travel with friends or family. Trips is free — and available to use no matter where you book.
This site uses cookies and other tracking technologies for essential, functional, analytical, and advertising purposes. By using the site, you agree to our Terms & Conditions and our Privacy Policy.
For more information about how we process your information, please see our Privacy Policy.
We value your privacy
momondo and its partners wish to use cookies or similar technologies to store and/or access information on and about your device and process personal data such as your IP address, device identifiers etc., in order to improve your experience on the site, to analyze navigation, to offer and measure personalized advertising, and to facilitate sharing on social networks. We also allow the use of third-party cookies (including those from our advertising partners) on our sites.
By clicking 'Accept', you consent to your data being processed by 0 vendors on this web site for the purposes described in this notice. You can review the vendors and their individual processing purposes on the .
To review individual processing purposes and cookie categories, please click ’Select individual purposes’. You can review your choices and withdraw your consent at any time by clicking the ’Privacy Preferences’ link in the page side navigation.