| January | February | March |
| Charlotte - Grand Cayman Is | 567 | - | - |
| Cincinnati - Cayman Brac Is | - | - | 567 |
| Las Vegas - Grand Cayman Is | 465 | - | - |
| Miami - Grand Cayman Is | 393 | - | - |
| Miami - Cayman Brac Is | 481 | - | - |
| New York - Grand Cayman Is | - | 560 | - |
| New York - Cayman Brac Is | - | 549 | - |
Found by another user in the last 24 hours. The fares are in USD including tax per adult.